State Department wants to make it harder to get a passport

If you don’t want it to get even harder for a U.S. citizen to get a passport — now required for travel even to Canada or Mexico — you only have until Monday to let the State Department know.
The U.S. Department of State is proposing a new Biographical Questionnaire for some passport applicants: The proposed new  Form DS-5513 asks for all addresses since birth; lifetime employment history including employers’ and supervisors names, addresses, and telephone numbers; personal details of all siblings; mother’s address one year prior to your birth; any “religious ceremony” around the time of birth; and a variety of other information.  According to the proposed form, “failure to provide the information requested may result in … the denial of your U.S. passport application.”

The State Department estimated that the average respondent would be able to compile all this information in just 45 minutes, which is obviously absurd given the amount of research that is likely to be required to even attempt to complete the form.
It seems likely that only some, not all, applicants will be required to fill out the new questionnaire, but no criteria have been made public for determining who will be subjected to these additional new written interrogatories.  So if the passport examiner wants to deny your application, all they will have to do is give you the impossible new form to complete.
It’s not clear from the supporting statement, statement of legal authorities, or regulatory assessment submitted by the State Department to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) why declining to discuss one’s siblings or to provide the phone number of your first supervisor when you were a teenager working at McDonalds would be a legitimate basis for denial of a passport to a U.S. citizen.
There’s more information in the Federal Register notice (also available here as a PDF) and from the Identity Project.
You can submit comments to the State Dept. online at  Regulations.gov until midnight Eastern time on Monday, April 25, 2011.  Go here, then click the “Submit a Comment” button at the upper right of the page. If that link doesn’t work for you, it’s probably a problem with the javascript used on the Regulations.gov website. There are alternate instructions for submitting comments by email here.
(Note that the proposed form itself was not published in the Federal Register. The Identity Project was eventually provided with a copy after requesting it from the Department of State, and posted it here.)
Here are the comments (PDF) being submitted by the Consumer Travel Alliance and other consumer, privacy, and civil liberties groups and individuals, if you would like to use it for ideas for comments of your own. (They’re also available  in OpenOffice format for easier editing.)
Extra points to the person who gives the best answer in the comments to the question on the proposed form, “Please describe the circumstances of your birth including the names (as well as address and phone number, if available) of persons present or in attendance at your birth.”
[Update: More than 3000 people and several organizations submitted comments opposing the proposal in the final days before the deadline. Those comments raise further concerns: It appears from some of the comments that the State Department is already using a version of this form, without the required OMB approval.]

Previous

Next

277 Comments

  1. dcta

    Well, let’s see – both my parents are now deceased and I am over 50 years old….I doubt there is anyone who would know the identity of everyone present at my birth. I know it was in the middle of the big March blizzard in NYC ion 1960 and it was at Brooklyn South Hospital. Of course, there is not more Brooklyn South Hospital. My mother once told me that the records of the hospital were all destroyed, so we can’t got that route to find out who the Attending Physicians, House Officers, and nurses were…. Mom was there – Dad was not. I know that my birth was an emergency C-section … hope that helps.

    Reply
  2. Hapgood

    After reviewing the proposed form, I wasn’t sure whether I should laugh or cry. It looks like something out of an absurdist, surreal satire on bureaucratic excess. As the Papers Please comments note, I doubt it would be possible for anyone to attempt the completion of the form without either committing perjury or being denied a passport for failing to provide information that there is no way to obtain, if it exists at all.
    But then I remembered that we’re waging a Global War on Terror. And it’s being led by a Homeland Security bureaucracy that specializes in spending enormous amounts of money arbitrarily imposing unfathomable and seemingly absurd requirements on citizens, always justified as necessary for “reasons of national security” that must remain secret.
    I think the Papers Please comments may have hit upon the real reason behind this form when they noted that it interferes with the right to travel, supposedly guaranteed by the Constitution and treaties. It has been clear for a while that the Homeland Security Department considers air travel not a right but a privilege. This privilege is granted or denied by the TSA according to criteria that are secret (for “reasons of national security”), and arbitrarily “interpreted” at the whim of individual officers.
    It now appears that the Homeland Security and State Departments are extending the TSA’s operating philosophy to international travel itself. International travel is no longer a right, but a privilege to be arbitrarily granted or denied according to secret criteria. This is, of course, necessary for reasons of “national security” and is not something to be questioned or challenged.
    Now that the proposed form has been publicized here (and I hope it’s picked up more widely), the State Department most likely will receive many negative comments about this utterly ridiculous proposal. It will be interesting to see what (if anything) they do with the comments.

    Reply
  3. sue

    I can’t find a legitimate news source (ie, not a blogger) that confirms this story. Are you sure that the writer of this story has his facts right?

    Reply
  4. sue

    I withdraw my former comment as I looked more closely at the source material for this article. I further ask – have you sent this to major media outlets?

    Reply
  5. Marilyn Long

    This form, if it actually becomes required for a passport, would exclude most people from international travel. Though I never moved often (43 years at current address) nor changed employment frequently (41 years with current employer), I would still find it difficult, probably impossible, to fill out this form. There are a couple of houses where I lived for one year during university. I could find the houses if they are still standing, but I have no idea what the house numbers were. Anyone who was present at my birth would be long dead or in their 90s and could not possibly be expected to remember an uneventful birth from almost 68 years ago. Then there is the one sibling who by his own choice ostracized himself from the rest of the family. I am hardly unique in having these “gaps” in my ability to supply information. If this were April 1, I would assume this story is a joke. I am preparing to teach 1984 in a literature class and I think this form will contribute to the discussion.

    Reply
  6. DaveS

    As others have said, there is no way I could possibly provide all my addresses since birth, phone numbers of dead employers, etc. Some of this information isn’t even researchable if one had the time and ability to spend hours looking for it. People have died, businesses have moved, records have been destroyed. I agree with the comment that this is yet another piece of security theatre – putting everyone to great trouble in the hopes of making it look like they’re doing something.

    Reply
  7. karla katz

    Almost too funny to think, but how many Congressmen/women, Cabinet Members, or, for that matter, President Obama himself, could answer ALL those questions?

    Reply
  8. DaveS

    “It will be interesting to see what (if anything) they do with the comments.”
    What they will probably do is put us on a watch list and give us extra scrutiny and screening if we have the temerity to want to fly.

    Reply
  9. kayt

    HAHA! Obama wouldn’t be able to leave the country!!!

    Reply
  10. Alan

    If the story is true, this is incredibly absurd! Just some questions to think about.
    Will the authorities actually check up on all of the submitted information? If so, I see a huge backlog, and demands for much more taxpayer money that will not enhance security!
    And, like many others, there’s no way I could find out all the information needed. The hospital I was born at is no longer a hospital, and I certainly don’t know the names, addresses, and phone numbers of the hospital staff that were present when I was born!
    Next question, will members of congress, who travel outside the country all the time be subject to these rules?
    This I know the answer to! Of course not! And neither will the higher ranking members of the State Dept or the TSA.
    Will it stop here? Probably not! I don’t know for sure, but I think I heard somewhere that the TSA wants to regulate ALL travel, including the eventual monitoring and random security checks for people traveling in their own cars! Including banning certain items in cars! People may think I’m nuts for even thinking this. I hope they turn out to be right! I hate to think that drivers in their own cars will be subject to being pulled over right and left and have half their items taken and be physically groped on their daily commutes by the TSA, and be subject to actions no local police force or highway patrol would be allowed to do!
    Oh, and one more thing. The link above to register opinions on this does not appear to be working. The page that came up stayed blank. I don’t know if it’s just a glitch, or the State Dept simply taking it down for awhile , for “Maintenance”?
    If we had a TSA, State Dept, and Homeland Security Dept that really believed in keeping us secure instead of getting drunk on their own power and collective egos, they’d talk with Israeli security and learn everything they can and follow their lead where apllicable. I understand that Israeli citizens do not have to put up with nearly as much as we do and the results for them have been better than for us here. When was the last time and El Al plane, or any plane, was hijacked out of Israel?

    Reply
  11. turtlerot1

    OK for an 8 year old first time applicant…..maybe. Now, for an 85 year old……forget it.
    Not clear – initial passport or renewals, also?

    Reply
  12. Hapgood

    DaveS, that’s exactly what makes me afraid to actually send them a comment about this.
    I think it’s very unlikely that the State Department or the DHS would put someone on a watch list for submitting a comment opposing the form. But the secrecy and lack of accountability of the DHS bureaucracy is exactly the environment that encourages officials to arbitrarily take that sort of vengeance against what they perceive as “unacceptable” conduct.
    The risk of that happening is probably minuscule, but the fear of it is well out of proportion to its likelihood. And speaking out probably would accomplish nothing. If the TSA is any indication, they don’t care what the public thinks of their “security enhancements.” So on balance, speaking out is probably not worth even the minuscule risk of retribution. Whoever proposed this form has most likely decided that it’s somehow necessary for national security, and they WILL use it however they want. They’re obligated to allow the public the opportunity to object, but they have no obligation to read to the objections.
    The fear of retribution for exercising what used to be a constitutional right indeed has a chilling effect. It’s probably the same reason few people bother to use the TSA’s official complaint process when they feel they’ve been wronged. But I’m sure Secretary Napolitano and Administrator Pistole consider that chilling effect beneficial. Their job is much easier when the public has been conditioned to behave as docile little sheep rather than continually whining about “rights” that only make the Homeland needlessly vulnerable to terrorists.

    Reply
  13. Hapgood

    Alan, the TSA claims that the SPOT program is their implementation of Israeli security. The GAO has found it completely lacking in either scientific validity or effectiveness, but the TSA would never let that stop them from expanding it (or from having Blogger Bob respond to the GAO report by proclaiming the program a success).
    The main reason genuine Israeli airport security would not be possible in this country is that it requires a large number of well-trained, conscientious, intelligent, and competent people to implement. There is no way the cop-wannabees the TSA dredges up to confiscate water bottles grope genitals could do anything like that. It’s just not possible, even if it could be scaled up from tiny Israel to the enormous US.
    The DHS and TSA bureaucracies are inherently capable only of the sort of security theatre we see at airports, and also the theatre of the absurd that the proposed passport form represents. They can only define “security” in terms of escalating intrusion and hassle that makes travel more difficult, with no reason to believe that it makes anyone safer. The unfortunate thing is that it indeed bamboozles a large number of Americans into BELIEVING that it keeps them safe, to the point where they eagerly defend the TSA from its detractors. And I suppose that’s the only “success” that matters to the DHS leadership.

    Reply
  14. Dave

    Guess I won’t be getting a passport anytime soon. Even if I had all of the information available I am not about to give it to the State Department. Spent 20 years in the Military including about 10 at various overseas locations and I have no idea about addresses etc. Looks to me like it’s going to be there loss. And yes my reps in congress are going to hear about it too.

    Reply
  15. Anna

    This is a belated April Fools Day joke, right?

    Reply
  16. SoBeSparky

    Considering the immigration citizenship bill in Arizona, if the far right gets ahold of this form, they will demand my circumcision certificate and who was there also.

    Reply
  17. Steve Wilson

    This is absurd. My father worked for the US Agency for International Development, I was in the US Air Force, — in short, in my 55 years, I have lived in well over 60 addresses. I couldn’t begin to reconstruct that from the past. …and knowing our good friends in Washington, if I screwed up just one address — NO PASSPORT FOR YOU!

    Reply
  18. Goose

    If you have a problem with this, simply click on the questionare link and start reaing it. No, I haven’t read it all, I stopped when I read what they were actually asking for. To start with, they are asking for your mother’s previous address, “if you weren’t born in an institution, where your birth is not recorded(or something like that)”. So most people in the USA should be fine, except may Obama.

    Reply
  19. Arp

    Even Kafka would think this is beyond absurd. How much time would they actually spend checking all this information? I think someone should come up with a boilerplate of stock answers that everyone can use.

    Reply
  20. Silver Fang

    If the federal government’s ultimate goal is to keep US citizens from traveling abroad, they’ve taken the important second step, the first being requiring a passport to go to Canada.

    Reply
  21. Charles

    I believe that this may be a cause of overreacting. I have read about this on various other sites. It seems that the Biographical Form is only for those people applying for a Passport that the DHS feels may deserve a closer look. (i.e. you are a child of Somali parents but were born in the US. You are a naturalized Citizen of the US but may still have citizenship and an address in another country., etc)
    This appears to be a request for DHS to come up with a Form to ask Questions for those who may not have the proper documentation for a US Passport. (This would also include several Native American/First Nation Tribal Members who may have traveled on a Native American/First Nation Passport in the past. There was an article about a LaCrosse team from upper New York State/Quebec that had extensively traveled on Tribal Passports for years but had no US Passport. They were told that they could attend a tourney in the UK but might not be able to return to the US using the Tribal Passport)
    I think this is just for cleaning up problems that have occurred with new regulations on International Travel.
    And to Steve Wilson, Thank you for your service. This Biographical Data Sheet should never come into play in your instance. You have (I assume) a current US Passport and should have no difficulties renewing. Now if you also carried a German Passport and had an address in Frankfurt, they may have you fill this out.
    Lots of worry about nothing IMO.

    Reply
  22. MeanMeosh

    Silver Fang – you don’t need a passport to get IN to Canada. You do need it, however, to return to the United States after your trip is over. Sort of the opposite of a Roach Motel – you can check out, but can’t check back in…

    Reply
  23. mary

    I have a feeling the only people who would know all those questions would be the terrorists themselves seeing how they like to do ample amounts of homework. So I’m thinking is you fail to answer the questions right you will get the passport. Those who get all them right I would flag because that’s just not human, lol. That’s just my hopeful thinking cause I really want to travel one day.

    Reply
  24. Hapgood

    Charles, how do you know what criteria the DHS or State Department will use to determine who “deserves a closer look” and needs to receive this questionnaire? That’s one of the problems the Papers Please comments point out, that an official in either organization can use it arbitrarily to deny anyone a passport. The DHS in particular already has too much authority to act arbitrarily, supposedly under criteria that are “classified for reasons of national security.”
    Goose, I recognize that the most absurd part of the questionnaire applies only to people who either weren’t born in a “medical facility” or took more than a year to have their birth officially recorded. Even so, I think these are the people who would be least likely to be able to locate the details of their mothers’ prenatal medical care, or even the name, address, and dates of the mothers’ employment. It would seem that anyone who wasn’t born in a hospital is, in practice, ineligible for a passport.
    But anyone else would still need to provide the address (including zip code) and dates of every place they’ve lived since birth, as well as the address, dates, and supervisor’s name and phone number of every employer they’ve ever had.
    The unlucky applicant may neither have all that information nor be able to find it. I know I could not answer that question for my earliest employers, since I don’t remember the exact address and phone number of two employers that ceased to exist years ago. And I don’t even know if those supervisors are still alive, let alone their phone numbers. But apparently I could be denied a passport for that failure, or perhaps even for filling in the only truthful answer that won’t subject me to prosecution for perjury: “I don’t know.” And what about self-employed applicants?
    It’s reasonable to be afraid that anyone “selected” to complete this questionnaire is effectively being arbitrarily denied a passport, since they are unlikely to be able to provide all the requested information. Even if they somehow can provide it, the task will surely take an order of magnitude more than the 45 minutes they’re estimating. For those reasons and numerous others, whoever is proposing this form needs to be sent back to his or her secure facility to come up with something other than a modernized version of the voter “literacy tests” that were once arbitrarily used to deny African-Americans their constitutional rights.

    Reply
  25. Hapgood

    Charles: “You have (I assume) a current US Passport and should have no difficulties renewing.”
    That assumes the DHS won’t insist on requiring completion of this questionnaire for either all or “selected” passport renewals. After all, the applicant’s first passport might have been granted decades ago, well before the DHS and the current “enhanced security.” It’s important to make sure a terrorist hasn’t been abusing the privilege of international travel.
    So let’s see…. Steve Wilson once made a comment critical of Form DS-5513. When he renews his passport, the official in the DHS who reviews the application checks the list of people who have spoken out in opposition to the DHS/TSA, and finds his name on it. That’s “suspicious,” so the official enters the code to require a Form DS-5513. He’s ultimately denied a passport because he left blank the phone number of a supervisor where he worked from 1967-1969. The Homeland is secure!
    Yes, that’s more than a little farfetched. But what really prevents a zealous DHS official from doing that?

    Reply
  26. Mike

    “Please describe the circumstances of your birth including the names (as well as address and phone number, if available) of persons present or in attendance at your birth.”
    I’m adopted, the records are sealed or otherwise unavailable. I would assume I was pushed through an opening between my birthmother’s legs, it probably happened at a hospital, and a doctor may have been present.

    Reply
  27. aaa

    Haha, it was just the same behind the iron curtain.
    The government didnt give passwords to anyone – because they would never come back.

    Reply
  28. zenon

    I think there are 0 people who can describe the people who were there at their birth. Thus you can deny the passport to anyone – “because they falsified / did not provide enough data about their birth”.
    This sounds quite funny from a country, who cannot provide the birth certificate of its own president (if there was nothing to hide, he would show the full form).

    Reply
  29. Terry Gilliam

    Reminds me a of a ground breaking film, Brazil.

    Reply
  30. Ave

    I am adopted. I have no idea who was present at birth or how long I was in the hospital. Then I went to foster care for two weeks. I don’t know that address. I’m assuming I’d have to fill in my adoptive parents’ and sibling’s info on the form, which I’d already be supremely uncomfortable doing. I don’t know – or care where my amom/adad lived the year before I was born. Futhermore, my amom is dead, and I don’t exactly talk to my adad because he was abusive. We also moved three times before I was three years old. No, don’t think I’ll ever be getting those addresses.
    Have they really never heard of foster care or homelessness or grown children who cannot talk to their parents for whatever? Jesus H Christ.

    Reply
  31. Mark Mahurin

    I’ve got an easier idea, State Dept. Just erect a 50 foot high, electrified concrete and Kevlar double fence with land mines in between around the entire nation.
    I’d have a better chance of getting through that then being able to answer all of questions you want to ask to get a passport.

    Reply
  32. Mary

    “If you have a problem with this, simply click on the questionare link and start reaing it. No, I haven’t read it all, I stopped when I read what they were actually asking for. To start with, they are asking for your mother’s previous address, “if you weren’t born in an institution, where your birth is not recorded(or something like that)”. So most people in the USA should be fine, except may Obama.”
    You are truly ignorant. Tons of people have no idea where their mother (or whoever is legally considered to be their mom) lived before their birth. Futhermore, plenty of people cannot find out – either because she’s dead, in prison, they’re in foster care, or is dangerous to them in some way. Basically this form would mean no one who was in foster care or orphaned or homeless or anything like that could ever get a passport. I guess that just means we’d have to do away with the military, seeing as foster kids migrate to it.

    Reply
  33. Mike Bordner

    Just another Stupid bunch of Government workers trying to keep their Jobs, This is about the dumbmest crap yet, and folks with our Gov. there is more to come, all I can say is UP YOURS to the Feds

    Reply
  34. Connie

    To all who may think this is a joke: I just checked the State Department site; it’s not a joke. This is a repeat of Nazi Germany. Here’s the
    the link.
    http://travel.state.gov/passport/passport_5401.html
    Enjoy your travel, you may not be able to get back in the country, and the way things are looking in this country, that’s just fine with me.

    Reply
  35. Robert

    Blame it on the birthers!

    Reply
  36. Ralph

    I’m sure Equifax, Trans Union et al will be offering to sell you your information in the near future 🙁

    Reply
  37. Jasono Pomario

    This is completely absurd! My father and I are immigrants from Bogata, Columbia and it seems that for people like us, it would be nearly impossible for us to get most of this information in a timely manner. Especially since I am mentally challenged and my Dad is in prison for Real Estate fraud. But when he gets out we plan on traveling the world in search of a new Mom for me! My current mother is a complete loser and has been working at Wal-Mart for years and dating a drug dealer who beats her. I am fed up with it and need a new Mom! How am I going to go on my Mom quest without a passport? Please don’t let the government make this any harder on me than it already is…. I am a vegetarian and I don’t have the energy or the will power to think for myself or anything!

    Reply
  38. Devian

    So in the fourth paragraph it says that not all people will have to fill out the info but that no criteria has been mentioned pertaining to who will and who won’t. This would give that State Dept power to discriminate absolutely.

    Reply
  39. Brandon

    Are you guys retarded? Did you even bother to read the form? The weird questions are only for people who weren’t born in a hospital or didn’t have their births registered like 99.9% of everyone else. They’re trying to collect information that would prove you are a citizen before giving you a passport. That’s kind of the point of a passport, you know? The document is supposed to worth something.
    The rest of the information isn’t anything that you can’t get from a credit report. . .that you can get free online. Not rocket science. Not worth spazzing out about. If you can’t answer the questions, just answer them to best of your ability. The people who examine these forms and approve the application are just looking at the totality of the information to make sure you are who you say you are. Oh lordy! Where’s my tinfoil hat?

    Reply
  40. Christy

    I’m wondering why this information is even necessary to begin with, especially questions like #9 – why is that information relevant to my passport application?
    What, if my mother received pre-natal care, I am more likely to be a threat to the US? There is no way for me to obtain that information, as anyone who was present at my birth (my mother and father) are dead. As in, deceased. As in, I cannot ask them any questions without the use of a necromancer or Ouija board.
    Additionally, why is my complete employment history required? Isn’t that on file with another spiffy government agency called Social Security? Oh, don’t forget about the IRS, they keep records for yeaaars. I don’t see how me working at Taco Bell 10 years ago is really relevant to me wanting to travel to say… Scotland, unless Taco Bell is scared I’m going to give away state burrito secrets.

    Reply
  41. Pwave

    I vaguely recall there was once a country that was famously difficult to leave precisely due to the bureaucratic mess it required: the USSR. The two sides of the [ex]-Iron Curtain have more in common than they liked to think after all…
    Incidentally, the government I was born under no longer exists, and I imagine many of its records are in a less-than-perfect shape. Though this also means the feds can’t verify easily them either, can they? Such a waste of already-scarce taxpayer dollars…
    Luckily, I have other citizenships to rely on for leaving…

    Reply
  42. Queue

    @Connie
    Hyperbole about Nazi Germany aside, the link you provided is about what sort of records need to be contained on your birth certificate to apply for a passport, principally that your full name appear as well as date and place of birth and seal. This isn’t unreasonable especially since the article links to a section on secondary evidence of citizenship for those whose birth certificates don’t measure up (e.g. my mom).

    Reply
  43. Claudia Gelli Larsson

    I don’t think this will ever pass. I’m not quite sure it’s even true. Has anyone read the original bill?

    Reply
  44. RushMyPassport

    It’s important to note that the State Department only expects 74,000 applicants a year to have to fill out the form – you’re only supposed to have to fill it out if your birth certificate was delayed or you were delivered by midwife.
    I agree it’s a lot of information. If you have to know all of that stuff to get a passport, many US citizens won’t be able to get passports. That said, if the State Department questions the legitimacy of your birth certificate, they already have the power to ask for additional information and documents- perhaps this form is just supposed to streamline that process?
    http://www.rushmypassport.com/blog/2011/04/state-department-considers-new-passport-form/

    Reply
  45. Are you trolling?

    “…but no criteria have been made public for determining who will be subjected to these additional new written interrogatories.”
    Actually, the criteria are RIGHT IN THE DOCUMENT.
    “Section C: Information for Non-Institutional Births or Delayed Birth Filings”
    So, yes, you alarmist retard, if you weren’t born in a hospital in the U.S., you’re going to have to come up with some info to prove you are who you say you are.

    Reply
  46. Angry Voter

    This is an obvious tip of the hand that they intend to make the US much, much worse and they don’t want us to be able to leave.
    The first freedom in any free state is the right to leave.
    When they take that, it won’t be a free country any more it will be one giant forced labor camp.

    Reply
  47. Simon Delancey

    It took me about 30 seconds on Google to discover that:
    1. The proposed biographical form is intended for people who cannot supply the normal proof of citizenship required for a US passport (ie, a birth certificate, consular report of birth abroad or naturalization certificate).
    2. The comment period that closes on April 29th is not for comments on the form itself, but for a plan to allow the US State Department to evaluate whether it is necessary, would impose an undue burden on applicants, etc. In other words, they’re asking for comments on the bureaucratic process.
    But hey, why let THE FACTS get in the way of a good old-fashioned panic, eh?

    Reply
  48. Henk

    I wanted to say this resembles a movie, but Terry beat me to it. Good movie btw, too bad you’re blowing your own trumpet.

    Reply
  49. J Christ

    The circumstances of my birth :
    My parents were temporarily relocated to Bethlehem and were unable to find a hospital for me to be born in. So, I was born in a barn.
    People present :
    Mary (mother). Address, Nazareth
    Joseph (surrogate father)
    Shepherds (address and names unknown)
    Melchior, Caspar, Balthasar (Intellectuals, approximate address “the east”)
    My employment supervisors were mostly angels, address Heaven.
    Do I get a passport now or does my early influence by radical intellectuals and a rather confused documentation about my birth (so confused that it has caused a few thousand years of religious conflict) make me ineligible?
    😉

    Reply
  50. State Dept. hypocrites

    The State Department is responsible for protecting human rights: they beat other countries over the head with them while denying them to American Citizens. This is a perfect example: a grave breach of Article 12 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. In Geneva, State promises to ‘bring human rights home.’ Someone should ask Harold Koh if this is what he meant.

    Reply
  51. QueenMab

    If this were to go through, who, exactly, in the bureaucracy would be responsible for researching all the answers listed in the form? What unfortunate flunky would have the onerous task of verifying all the information on the form and proving no perjury has been committed and no errors made? If the person applying for the passport (who has a vested interest in having the information as accurate as possible) can’t successfully fill all those required fields, how is an ordinary clerk, processing these things day in and day out, going to fact check it – and what incentive does he have to even *care* about verifying it?
    Another example of attempts at legislation in which NO thought whatsoever is being given to the actual execution of the task.

    Reply
  52. DaveX

    President Barack Obama was present at my birth, along with a throng of well-wishers including Muhammad Ali (who briefly changed his name BACK to Cassius Clay for the occasion), Penny Marshall, Cat Stevens, and Michael Moore (whose documentary of my birth was unfortunately destroyed.)
    Gary Coleman and Uma Thurman scattered flowers throughout the hospital, while Willie Nelson announced my arrival with blasts of his tuba. I distinctly remember the scent of burning jasmine, emanating from the elephant-shaped, hand-beaten copper masks of the medical staff.
    My mother was present, but my father was busy discussing politics with Udo Kier in the vending area. Having little money at the time, my father offered to split his Zagnut with Mr. Kier, who refused.
    Although not among those invited, Margot Kidder was also present, clad entirely in see-through red lace, mistakenly conflating astrological signs of my upcoming birth with that of an ex-lover to be married on the same day– remarkably, in the room next door! I am told by family scholars that my gift of fondue knives was well-received, and employed to this day fondly by the happy couple.
    (I can be reached at the several above addresses and phone numbers if the State Department wishes me to provide copies of their wedding certificate, employment history, and sworn statements of sexual congress.)

    Reply
  53. Grand Inquisitor

    J Christ, your passport applicant will be denied. Clearly, neither of your parents are American citizens, and there is no proof that you ever visited America much less was born there. If you wish, you can contest this determination with proof that one or both parents are American citizens. However, since America was not in existence at the time of your birth, we feel this would be impossible. It is possible to become a naturalized citizen, at which time, you should feel free to fill out the long form application for a passport detailing with specificity every detail of your life from the time of Adam and Eve onwards. Currently, however, we only allow immigrant carpenters on an H1B visa which would be impossible to convert to a green card, so expect the naturalization process to take up to 100 years if it occurs at all.

    Reply
  54. Fletcher

    Enjoy your freedom, USA.

    Reply
  55. VHM

    Extra points to the person who gives the best answer in the comments to the question on the proposed form, “Please describe the circumstances of your birth including the names (as well as address and phone number, if available) of persons present or in attendance at your birth.”
    ________
    I was born in Illinois with my mother in attendance at the birth but my birth certificate says I was born in Indiana with only a father. Talk about an immaculate birth!
    I plead the 5th on answering any more of the question, because it is illegal for me to know the answer, and therefore I would be incriminating myself.
    ______
    If only I were joking. Prior to this, many adoptees who hadn’t gotten their passports prior to 9/11 have been unable to get one (and sometimes even a driver’s license, depending on the state). Now, every single adopted or fostered person will be in the same boat.
    But not, of course, a boat sailing into any international waters. Can’t have that.

    Reply
  56. VHM

    This is turning into a birther comment thread? Seriously?
    I wish I had all the legal proof Obama has about his birth and his early years. But I’m just an adoptee, with significantly fewer human and civil rights than the rest of you. It’s actually illegal for me to know the information being requested. So if I answer the questions, I’m incriminating myself. If I don’t, I can’t get a passport.
    I’d love to have the Republican governor of my state declare publicly where and when I was born, and to whom. That would be awesome.

    Reply
  57. Harmy G

    I would like to describe the details of my conception…

    Reply
  58. Matt

    Persons present at birth: My Mother, My Father, the crazy white haired doctor that reminds me of Christopher Lloyd in Back to the Future, that really hot Asian nurse who’s phone number I wish I had kept for 20 years until I was of dating age; that creepy male nurse – really what self respecting man was a male delivery room nurse in the 70’s – I think he was there to pick up my mother.
    Oh! God, Jesus and their pall Casper were all present – Current location of these three nefarious individuals is unknown and I believe that their presence was an attempt to permanently enroll me in an army that was not under the power of the United States government – Brain washing was certainly part of their reason for being there.

    Reply
  59. Bill in Tennessee

    Who would it affect? Let me tell you who it would affect….anyone the administration sees as a “trouble maker”… anyone who criticizes any politician or the sitting President. Anyone who thinks TSA (a.k.a. T&A) goes too far in their heavy petting / pat-downs of suspects, formerly called travelers. Anyone who espouses certain conservative or libertarian values would also be targeted. I see where this is going, and Orwell would have been SO proud of the State Department.

    Reply
  60. Hapgood

    Grand Inquisitor, there is ample, indisputable proof that Mr J Christ made repeated trips to America. You need only wait for a pair of friendly teenagers dressed in crisp white shirts to knock on your door. They’ll present you with a book containing a complete account of Mr Christ’s visits (as verified by witnesses with impeccable credentials who saw the genuine metal plates on which the proof was originally inscribed). And they’ll spend as much time as you need to answer any questions you might have.
    The circumstances of Mr Christ’s birth are fully documented in an even more authoritative and widely-circulated book whose veracity and accuracy have been unquestioned for centuries. Unfortunately, that book has significant lacunae that would preclude the issuance of a passport under the new regulations. Specifically, it contains no information about his mother’s prenatal and postnatal medical care, or her employer. Since the people who might have had that information have been dead for nearly two millennia, I’m afraid that Mr Christ will have to be denied a passport.
    But if that’s what the DHS and State Department determine are necessary to keep our Homeland secure, I support it 1000%! To do otherwise would aid the enemy.

    Reply
  61. eric

    The blog author might want to re-read this form and issue a deflammatory statement. This information appears to be somewhat incorrect. People are freaking out about this. Please re-check the jargon in the formwork and re-consider your rhetoric. While, yes, it is singling out some parties unfairly, perhaps, it is probably not targeting the audience your inciting.
    It is CLEARLY aiming specifically at home-birthing:
    “Section C: Information for Non-Institutional Births or Delayed Birth Filings”
    “If you were not born in the United States skip Items 5-12 and continue to Section D. If you were born in the United States,
    you must complete Items 5-12 if you answer “No” to either of the questions below.”
    “Was your birth recorded within one year of the date your birth occurred?”
    “Were you born in a medical facility?”
    Please seriously consider re-drafting this notice.
    Thank you,
    Eric

    Reply
  62. jt

    Thanks for the heads up on this – I just sumbitted a comment

    Reply
  63. Sandy

    Really??? I wouldn’t even be able to fill out the form completely for my twin children, who have no job history and have lived only at our current address! I know that my husband, my mother, and my doctor were at their birth. However, I have no idea who the other doctor was, who the other people in the room were, or even exactly how many were there! I think it was about a dozen in all, but I didn’t stop to get their names and phone numbers. I was kinda busy at the time, you know, giving birth!

    Reply
  64. Edward Hasbrouck

    @eric – Is there some reason why hospital birth should be required for a passport? Or why people not born in hospitals (at home, in a car or ambulance on the way to the hospital, etc.) should be denied passports? Portions of the proposed form would be required for everyone the State Department, in its infinite wisdom, requires to answer the form. And people not born in hospitals would, in general, be even less likely to be able to answer the other questions on the form.

    Reply
  65. Triceratops horridus

    As a Triceratops, I was born 65 million years ago in what is currently the State of Montana.
    Unfortunately, I no longer have a birth certificate, as the fiery conflagration that consumed the planet a few years after my birth pretty much destroyed anything remotely flammable in my neighborhood. Also, we didn’t have the ability to write, nor did we have writing materials.
    Present at the time were my mother and my several siblings. As my mother died in the above-mentioned fire and my siblings were too busy hatching from their own eggs to note my birth, I regrettably do not have any extant witnesses to my emergence into the USA.
    As the US Postal Service was not in existence at the time of my birth, I do not have any addresses to provide to you that would be of relevance. Additionally, the subsequent drifting of the continents also renders latitude and longitude locations problematic. Same for subsequent geomagnetic reversals and polar wander.
    My education and employment history is difficult to describe in human terms, as Cretaceous ceratopsids were mainly concerned with reproduction, eating enough food to stay alive, and avoiding Cretaceous tyrranosaurids. For us, knowledge would basically be experience based, and not classroom based.
    I hope these problems do not interfere with my passport application. Despite my lack of official documentation, I lived, died and still live in the USA. You may come and interview me in St. Paul, MN – ask for Fafner at the front desk of the Science Museum of Minnesota.
    http://www.smm.org/100objects/paleontology/triceratops/

    Reply
  66. Aunti

    I’m especially appreciative of the regulations.gov comment form fields that would be publicly viewable — including my name, address, and phone number. If asking intrusive, “security theater” questions is supposed to enhance my personal security, the comment form kinda defeats that doesn’t it? 🙂

    Reply
  67. Chasmosaur

    @eric:
    Yes, the information is for those who were not born in the USA.
    But if they are applying for a US Passport, they need to be citizens. Which mean that not only did they jump through all the hoops required for the citizenship process, they also went through a similar set of hoops for their green card (which technically had to be kept on their person at all times – do you have to keep your passport or birth certificate on hand at all times?).
    Legal immigrants are documented out the yin-yang. Even without all the birth-related information, this is insulting. The first time you apply for a security clearance, they only ask you to go back 10 years, not all the way back to your infancy.
    While the Feds do have an insane amount of info about our lives at their fingertips, I don’t want to give the State Department – so recently and easily outed by WikiLeaks – a 5 page form with my entire existence on it.
    A passport is just used to determine your identity, and are a citizen of a country and eligible for international travel. That is it. It is not meant to be your entire history.

    Reply
  68. CC

    Ah, America. Land of the Free.

    Reply
  69. John

    Edward … Actually the answer to your question is yes. People who were not born in a hospital or had their birth recorded immediately may not be citizens of the US. Since the primary purpose of a passport is to prove citizenship, I think that it would be important for an applicant to prove that he/she was actually born in the US or naturalized (in either case making them a citizen). The additional information is required to give the government verifiable information that you were, in fact, born in the US and entitled to hold a passport.
    I love how this document is being blown way out of scale.

    Reply
  70. Lee

    Delayed April Fool’s joke??

    Reply
  71. Joe Buck

    @John: a person not born in a hospital may require additional investigation, true, to establish that he/she was born in the USA as claimed. However, since pretty much no one could provide the information requested, this amounts to denying passports for all such people. This means that the bureaucrats need to go back to the drawing board and figure out what they really need to know. The form could ask for as much information about the circumstances of the birth as is known, plus contact information for witnesses. It’s ridiculous to ask for the dates of all prenatal appointments. Ask your own mother if she would be able to fill out the form for you.

    Reply
  72. VHM

    Responding to a point several posters have made:
    Many adoptions are not processed and filed within 12 months of a adoptee’s birth. It may even be years later. When an adoption is completed, then a new birth certificate is created with new information on it, based on the adoptive parents’ information rather than the adoptee’s. The file date for the birth certificate is not back-dated, and nothing on the birth certificate will indicate that it is anything other than a vital record of birth, so it will appear to be filed too late to fulfill the State Department’s new regulations. It will also be filled with false information that can cause the document to be flagged as problematic and possibly forged.
    This affects about 5% of the population. It’s not as small a problem as some people think.

    Reply
  73. Tristan Alexander

    This is idiotic and illegal and unconstitutionla and just beyound any reason! NO ONE can answer any of those questions and getting a passport is NOT easy as it is! So please, whoever deamed this up, go get your head examined and chek into a rehab and forget ALL about this idiotic idea! Sheesh!

    Reply
  74. DLP

    It is ALREADY too hard to get a US Passport. I had to try 3 times, write a furious letter, and dump every baby picture, rental and tax record, and family history scrap I had on them. I think I finally got mine because they did not want to go through the enormous stack of supporting documentation I sent in angry response to my third refusal.
    What is the purpose of this change? Why make it so much harder? These questions sound utterly ridiculous. It should be much simpler than this. To actively prevent US Citizens from traveling abroad and proving citizenship is a violation of our rights.
    And now, without a passport, we can’t even go to Canada… I live near the border and have found that the last few years, even with a passport, I have received so much hassle going through, I just don’t try. The last time, the Canadians searched me, the car, and wanted to run background checks on me and my companion in every state we’d ever lived in, when we were simply on our way to eat out at a Chinese restaurant in our local border town. (Did I say how ordinary and innocuous I and my friend looked–and are?).
    Border communities have suffered from this increased harassment and the passport hassles. Why reach the ridiculous decision to make things even harder?

    Reply
  75. little gator

    I was born in Boston Lying-In Hospital, which no longer exists. It changed its name to Boston Womens’ Hospital and then merged with Peter Bent(source of much teen snickering) Brigham to become Brigham and Womens’, and then I lost track. The building I was born in is no longer a hospital but I suppose Brigham and Wigham(as I call it) has my birth records if any hospital does.
    My mother was in the room but my father wasn’t, as was traditional in the 1950s. I know the last name of her obstetrician at the time but I don’t know whether he personally attended my birth. Other than that, there were a bunch of medical types but I don’t know any of their names. I was delivered by C-section so there may have been lots of doctors and nurses and such in the room.
    My only source for this information is my mother, who is either telling the truth or a very good and consistent liar. Or maybe deluded.
    I am not making any of this up.

    Reply
  76. Tristan Alexander

    This is idiotic and illegal and unconstitutional and just beyond any reason! NO ONE can answer any of those questions and getting a passport is NOT easy as it is! So please, whoever dreamed this up, go get your head examined and check into a rehab and forget ALL about this idiotic idea! Sheesh!
    (sorry for the bad spelling/typing before)

    Reply
  77. nobody special

    It would be nice if all you people bitching and raising pitchforks would actually read the form you’re screaming about.

    Reply
  78. Jimmy Malmay

    This just goes to show that when you have a criminal or foreign occupation government they go out of their way to make life as difficult as they can on you it is like a form of harassment to make everything so stupid and difficult, they are just trying to make this country a living hell. This is not about harassing the people from other countries it is about harassing the American citizens.

    Reply
  79. Cindy S. Roshon

    Frankly, I don’t understand how the proposed information to be gathered, other than proof of US citizenship and lack of a criminal conviction, has any bearing on whether or not a US citizen should receive a passport. Forty-five minutes should be ample time to fill out the questionnaire, including time for research?? Are you serious? It would be impossible for me to fill out the form completely–I have lived at over 40 different addresses in the past 35 years, and I have been employed in many different fields, much of it contract labor or self-employment. Multiple companies or individuals for whom I have worked are out of business, and I have no idea how to contact them or retrieve their addresses and telephone numbers. I am a US citizen and have a completely clean record, not even a traffic ticket, yet my failure to include this impossible-to-accurately-provide (proposed) date could result in denial of my passport? Unfortunately, this will most likely be the widespread result–thousands of otherwise eligible US citizens’ travel abroad will be restricted. What do we have when a country begins to restrict its own citizens from travel outside it’s borders? … Somehow this sounds vaguely familiar… First hand up in class gets the prize…

    Reply
  80. MWR

    “Please describe the circumstances of your birth including the names (as well as address and phone number, if available) of persons present or in attendance at your birth.”
    Well, my father was a gambler down in Georgia. He wound up on the wrong end of a gun. And me? I was born in the back seat of a Greyhound bus, rolling down highway 41. Presumably my mother was present at the time, as well as a small contingent of hardscrabble folks making their way to the big city in search of work. Also one crazy-eyed guy with a harelip.
    (I’m not certain about that last one, but every Greyhound has one of those guys, so it’s a fair bet.)

    Reply
  81. MWR

    Nobody Special:
    I DID read the form, and it’s ridiculous. How would any “religious activities” surrounding my birth have any bearing on my eligibility for a passport? Will they go back in time and find evidence of my baptism to prove that I am in fact who I say I am?
    If my mother has passed away, how can I know if she did or did not receive pre- or post-natal care? And why the heck does it matter?
    I have no idea where my mother worked before I was born, and I have NO idea where she lived a year before I was born.
    It’s invasive and unnecessary.

    Reply
  82. laura

    God, I hope not!
    Every employment? Including contracting? Not sure I can even remember. About 15 years ago when filled out paperwork for my security clearance with the Navy, I spent weeks reconstructing my life to input all the data required (all previous adfresses, names of former neighbors, former employers, etc.). The one I really liked was the requirement to list neighbors that I didn’t know well from previous residences…if I didn’t know them that well, how would I remember their names 20 years later?
    Anyway, it was so difficult to remember all the stuff that the one smart thing I did was to copy it before I submitted it, so I would always have all the informaiton (at least up until that point in time) readily available.
    These new rules would be a serious handicap to all those military dependents with pages of former addresses, all those who have entered the new reality of serial employment v. lifetime employment, etc.
    Some of the proposed requierments might violate privacy and religious rights, or require you to violate the rights of others.
    Extra points answer: I cannot provide details because there is credible proof that I was switched at birth with another.

    Reply
  83. Andy

    Personally, I believe the government went through a great deal of thinking/planning for this process, mainly for the advantage of having even more control over the people! After all, this country hasn’t technically been “free” for quite some time; it becomes more of a police state every day! Beware of Big Brother, because he’s definitely searching you out! Of course, it’s still just as easy as it was before for a criminal to get his “information”; now it’s only more difficult for true citizens to prove they are who they say!

    Reply
  84. eric

    @Edward Hasbrouck … No, of course there is no justifiable reason for this. It is prejudiced and unfair. I am completely against it. However, that was not the point I was making. The point I was making is that this article suggests this affects ALL US citizens. It does not. That is all. I just think the author is conveying misinformation. I don’t think the author is doing this maliciously or anything. I just think the bureaucratic red-tape BS needs to be waded through a bit more carefully before bringing it to press. People are panicky about this and they need not be.
    @Chasmosaur … Sorry but no “the information is for those who were not born in the USA” is just wrong. You, as most everyone else, have misread this. It is specifically making things more difficult for those who were not born in hospitals. Why? I have no idea. It says, if you are not a citizen, you can skip that whole insane section. Others have suggested that reducing the number of passports issued can save the government billions of dollars. While I believe we MUST repair our economy, I strongly believe that giving up fundamental freedoms, such as the one to travel in and out of our own country, cannot be surrendered.
    I also believe in free speech.
    That being said, if we could focus more appropriately on the word of the law here, as a group, we could effect more meaningful change.
    Instead, we are all enraged and leaving irrelevant comments, then patting ourselves on the back, all the while not realizing we are leaving the inappropriate response to the wrong issue.

    Reply
  85. Adoptee

    “Please describe the circumstances of your birth including the names (as well as address and phone number, if available) of persons present or in attendance at your birth.”
    I’m adopted, therefore I can make no truthful statement that accords with my documentation, as my “long form” birth certificate lists my adoptive parents as my “birth” parents and we were not all in the same state when I was born. I can likewise not be certain that any other persons listed on said document were there or not, nor does any other record exist, according to Catholic Charities and the fire department that failed to stop that hospital from burning down in the 80’s.
    Apparently I am now an illegal immigrant, because if I leave I can’t come back, and if I wait until after Monday to apply for a passport renewal, I will never be allowed to legally leave the country again.
    I’m beginning to think emigration is going to be less of an overall hassle than staying here.

    Reply
  86. cyndi

    dear state department-did my mother receive prenatal care-how would i know this – i was holed up in her uterus.

    Reply
  87. Smarty

    So now your religion will be on your passport?
    Obama had to supply a long-form birth certificate to get his passport, and yet he won’t share. I think someone tried to share (or his people tried to cover up) with the “Great State Department Passport Coverup” during the primaries. I wonder what Obama’s supporting documents say.

    Reply
  88. lulubee

    @nobody special-“It would be nice if all you people bitching and raising pitchforks would actually read the form you’re screaming about.”
    I read the form, and it’s even crazier than described in the article. As far as who has to fill out the form, the State Dept.’s supporting info says, “The Biographical Questionnaire for a U.S. Passport, form DS-5513, is used to supplement an application for a U.S. passport when the applicant submits citizenship or identity evidence that is insufficient or of questionable authenticity.” Whether that means lacking a birth certificate or something else is anybody’s guess–more specific information wasn’t given. It sounds as if the passport office could give you the weird form if they think your birth certificate is faked–I don’t know what the criteria for that would be.
    I find that the State Dept.’s supplementary information is badly supported. They state that their “45 minutes” estimate to fill out the form is based on test subjects filling it out, but doesn’t say whether those people answered every question. I think it would take most people a lot longer than that. They also state that there would be no additional cost to implementing these new regulations, but since the requested information is more detailed than in the past (even for people w/o birth certificates), it’s obvious it would take a lot more time to go through and verify it.
    I would like to know whether leaving out some of the information would be grounds to deny the passport, if the rest of the info given is sufficient to verify citizenship. The form itself says, “please complete this form in its entirety.” But the current system doesn’t require ALL of this info, so why have they changed it?

    Reply
  89. Hapgood

    eric, as best as I can tell the proposed form DOES affect anyone who applies for a passport, whether or not they were born in the U.S. or in a hospital. Those whose birth in a hospital was recorded within a year don’t have to fill in the section about the circumstances of their birth and their mother’s doctor appointments, but they do have to provide every address and employer they’ve had since birth. Failing to do that completely and correctly could result in the denial of a passport.
    While the notice in the Federal Register says that only about 45,000 people will be “selected” to fill in the form, potentially ANY applicant could be “selected” under unspecified (and probably classified) criteria. The notice also says that gathering up all the information and completing the form takes 45 minutes, a claim whose credibility is on a par with Saddam Hussein’s weapons of mass destruction. So why should we believe that the form will affect only a few people who weren’t born in an American hospital? The potential for abusing the form to arbitrarily deny passports (perhaps to people who submitted comments in opposition to the form?) is simply too great.
    Also, there doesn’t seem to be any “word of the law” involved here. This looks like yet another unfathomable and absurd policy unacountable DHS bureaucrats have created in secret to restrict people’s rights, supposedly in the name of “security.”
    Finally, if you are not a citizen you can skip not just “that whole insane section” but the entire form. You’re not entitled to a U.S. passport under any circumstances. And the “irrelevant comments” are, of course, in response to Mr Hasbrouck’s offer of “extra points” for the best answer to the section of the section about the circumstances of birth. Perhaps he has the right idea. This form is so absurd that it (and whoever came up with it) deserves to be laughed off the stage. In the words of Stephen Sondheim, “laugh at the kings or they’ll make you cry.”

    Reply
  90. chaim Wurdy

    It pays to be a dual citizen in case you have to leave in a hurry. That other passport can get you out to safely same day.

    Reply
  91. Victor

    That’s kinda jacked. They’re basically encouraging mothers to give birth in hospitals, which unless their is a special medical reason, really is not necessary monetarily, nor for the comfort of the mother or the child.
    Annoying.

    Reply
  92. Blue

    I have no idea who was there at my birth. Both my Mother (deceased) and I were a little busy at the time or I’m quite sure one of us would have passed a Guest Book. Doctor Limbert (deceased) didn’t care about social conventions to do it. Sister Claudrika (deceased) wasn’t worldly enough. It’s not with my baby book so I’m pretty sure neither of the other nurses passed one either. Who would have ever thought that something so small being overlooked would have such major ramifications.
    Are they nuts?

    Reply
  93. Renee

    Several people seem to be missing the fact that you can indeed be born outside of the US and still be a US citizen as long as a) at least 1 parent is a US citizen or b) you’re a naturalized citizen, hence why some people filling out that form could just skip section C and go straight to section D altogether. The form is ridiculous – if I were chosen for it, I’d have to answer an awful lot of unknowns to it. I can’t even fathom where they got the estimate of 45 minutes to fill out the form – that would be true certainly if I had all the information at hand, but of course collecting said information could take forever, or may never happen.

    Reply
  94. Circe

    My brother was born at home & had nuchal cord issues. Paramedics had to be called. Would he have to track down their names & contact info too? Seriously.

    Reply
  95. Roger

    For my birth?
    Well I know my mom’s and my dad’s name and phone number, but we have no idea who the taxicab driver is!
    At least my parents gave a really generous tip!

    Reply
  96. Carol

    All present at my birth now live in heaven (I hope). If you have any success contacting them, please let me know as I too would love to hear from them.

    Reply
  97. Rodney Goddard

    This is just a way for an impotent department to show it can count for something, After all who needs the State Department.,when all the US foreign policy is handled either by the President or the Department of Defense.

    Reply
  98. Just wondering...

    45 minutes is probably the time they got after the test subjects got tired of the stupid questions and just started making things up.
    I have a passport, and just last week used it to visit old friends in Berlin, who would be pretty disturbed, I think, to hear that the same country that once risked so much to drop them food from the sky is now ready to take the ‘nobody leaves here’ approach from its citizenry. It’s a bit tougher to tunnel under the ocean than a wall, but will people start jumping out of windows and hiding in carseat covers to get to Canada?

    Reply
  99. Bronwyn

    I was born. I’m pretty sure I was. I check daily, and apparently, it’s still true. I still have a bellybutton and a short-form birth certificate that tells me a date.
    I remember turning 5, and my teacher bought me cupcakes. My teacher, Sister Margaret, was clearly in a position of authority, and therefore those cupcakes prove my birthdate. She would not have bought me cupcakes had it not been my birthday, ergo she was in a position to *know*, ergo even after moving *between continents* in those 5 years, my teacher must have been there at my birth.
    Knowing Sister Margaret, she ineffectually fluttered between muttering the stations of the cross and patting my mother’s hand as my mother went through *DAYS OF AGONIZING LABOR* for which I still have to buy Mother’s Day cards — in which I still must fit my adult handspan outline (in red crayon) on the left side of the card. And buy nice flowers. And still get told off about that one incident, 30 years ago, when I “cleaned my room” by shoving the entire contents under the bed.
    I was clearly born on my birthday. Sister Margaret and my mother agree. If you’d like to reach Sister Margaret, I’m sure the Vatican has her current details.
    Is there space for that on the form?

    Reply
  100. KLM

    Forget the birth details: In the past almost 5 decades I’ve moved at least 27 times, in 7 states and overseas. I’ve had 14 employers as well, several of which have long since gone out of business, or merged and rendered and been taken over to an extent that the company and location I worked for effectively doesn’t exist.
    I don’t even know the details of the first half dozen addresses (againsome of which no longer exist which I expect would get my app rejected when the confirmation researcher looks them up on google maps and discovers parking lots and shopping centers instead) and it would take me well longer than 45 minutes of Internet searching to recreate details of my first several employers.

    Reply
  101. Perry3

    I have no problem with this form as long as only the “birthers” are the ones who have to fill it out. It would be impossible for me to fill a good bit of that information without help from my family, as it would be for so many others, and many of us have a parent or parents who have gone on to the great beyond. However, I propose that in determining who has to fill out the “long form”, that they be asked if they swear that they believe that the President of the United States is a citizen of the US. If they can’t answer that, give them the long form.
    Seriously, though, this form reminds me of the kinds of things that were done to blacks to prevent them from voting in the South during most of the last century i in the Southeastern region of the United States. For example, they might be asked something cruel like “how many bubbles are there in a bar of Ivory soap”. Any answer would be wrong according to the white administrator giving the test.
    It also reminds me of comments from former Soviet Bloc citizens who often remarked and still remark that during the Communist regime’s years of power it was impossible not to be guilty of something, therefore it was easy to put dissidents in prisons, mental hospitals and other places to keep their knowledge of how corrupt the system was from the cizenry.
    . Incidentally, how could one give a zip code address when zip codes were not even in existence until the latter half of the twentieth century. Or if a street named has been changed, does one use the new or old street address. And for some areas, like Folly Beach SC, thousands of addresses have disappeared into the ocean. How might one retrieve such an address? The street signs did not stay under the water when the streets disappeared due to the rising ocean and receding land mass so a scuba set will not help you. .

    Reply
  102. Elizabeth Branch

    I am a Third Culture Kid, meaning I grew up living overseas for the large majority of my life. I moved 8 times by the time I graduated from high school, went to 9 different schools. How the heck am I supposed to remember all those addresses? This is just plain ridiculous. The government already knows all this stuff about us, don’t they?

    Reply
  103. J.C Christ

    I am told that I was born in a manger in Bethlehem due to my parents having to travel their to register so that they could give to Rome what belonged to Rome. A number of wise men from the East were also present as well prescient shepherds as well as their flocks, who may or may not have had human cognition. An innkeeper was close by as he directed my mother and my non father to shelter themselves until the counting was over. My real father was said to be present although the rest of those present at the scene swore that they never saw him there. I had a number of jobs in the interim, one of them being to shake down the money changers at the Temple. This did not set over well with my parents so I gave up that occupation for a while and became a carpenter’s apprentice. But the gall of those Pharisees who continued to steal from the people convinced me that I should go forth into the world and gather up 12 authoritarian followers who help me do my bidding and accomplish the task that I set out to do. A number of clergy now say that I traveled to places such as Great Britain, India and even to the land that I am now trying to obtain a passport from so that I can change the people’s thinking there on war and other behavior which I disapprove of, but some of my visitation at these other placesis in dispute. For a time I traveled to Egypt as a ruler like George Bush (named Herod – he was quite the torture candidate) called for all male children born during the period that I was born to be killed. I am not sure how this act was accomplished untiI I understood from the society I live in that war is the method by which young males are killed today. One United States General remarked just a few years ago that we had a “fine crop of young men and women” who could likewise serve in the military and be killed just as Herod had ordained that it should happen to me. It’s so nice to hear those great Generals referring to our young people as crops to be “harvested”, much like we do with ears of corn and the like. But it wasn’t until several years later that Herod’s men got me by hanging me on a cross but I managed to escape by rising to heaven and I generally make a visit to earth every now and again, although my mother is said to make more frequent visits than I do, one church being particularly adapt at marking places where she has made appearances, although I try to keep my distance from that church as they have a good many child abusers sheltered there, which I don’t approve of. Some of these places where my mother has made appearances are quite famous, such as a particular spot in France called Lourdes. I am afraid that I shall never get through this form so the citizens of the United States are just going to have to do without me. I think that I shall reside in the meantime with a jolly old gentlemen I know who lives at the North Pole but I think that it would be in my best interest to stay away from the United States of America, the culture being more warlike than the Roman one where I lived as a young man.

    Reply
  104. Portia

    I was born alone, as my parents were on vacation in Italy. They left me some diapers at the ready and bottles in the warmer, though, so I was fine. Unfortunately this means I have no human witnesses to my birth except my mother’s goldfish who watched me curiously from the aquarium.

    Reply
  105. Donna L. Gates

    How in the world do you expect seniors to remember all of this when
    we have trouble remembering our own names and today’s date?
    Sounds like a witch hunt to me..

    Reply
  106. Jeff

    Freedom!

    Reply
  107. Ramblin' Man

    I was born in the backseat of a greyhound bus, rolling down highway 41.

    Reply
  108. Tania

    This is crazy! How am I supposed to remember all that information, let alone retrieve it? What about people that are adopted? They may not be able to even get this information if they tried. So are you saying they can’t have a passport??? This is so absurd!

    Reply
  109. Aldonza

    I was spawned in a ditch
    By a mother who left me there,
    Naked and cold and too hungry to cry;
    I never blamed her.
    I’m sure she left hoping
    That I’d have the good sense to die!
    Then, of course, there’s my father…
    I’m told that young ladies
    Can point to their fathers
    With maidenly pride;
    Mine was some regiment
    Here for an hour,
    I can’t even tell you which side!
    [I guess I can’t get a passport. Especially if I’m traveling with that deranged Alonzo Quijana guy who insists that my name is “Dulcinea.” ]

    Reply
  110. Alecta Megarea

    Absurd! These lawmakers are insane.

    Reply
  111. Jay Hallon

    All this will make it harder (or at least much more cumbersome) for many people to get a passport, and this is a nation who already has a smaller share of people with passports than any other western country. We’re already not a nation that’s curious about other countries, ostensibly because everything here is so perfect and we don’t “need” anybody else. These new rules will only exacerbate our condition.

    Reply
  112. Kristi

    These are some EXCELLENT points about why this is absurd…please submit them to the State Department!!!!

    Reply
  113. Jay Schmidt

    This form doesn’t even come up to the level of stupid. It’s not just stupid, it’s Sarah Palin stupid.

    Reply
  114. Lauren Korman

    Why does it matter where my mother lived the year before I was born? What does this mean for kids who were adopted? Does the State Department want to know where the biological mother lived or where the adopted mother lived? This proposal is truly absurd. Are our tax dollars going to hire people to monitor this ridiculous proposal when we don’t even have enough money to pay enough IRS agents to collect and review taxes? Wake up and smell the coffee. Please recognize the fact that this is a bad idea and if it goes through, our tax dollars are going to have to pay for it.

    Reply
  115. Liz Norberto

    Why arent these questions for people who DONT PAY TAXES. I PAY MY TAXES!!! Therefore I have every right to obtain a passport as a TAX PAYING AMERICAN CITIZEN!!!

    Reply
  116. Brain Hertz

    Yikes. That really is pretty crazy.
    This doesn’t directly impact me. Yet. I’m a British citizen, but eligible to apply for naturalization in about a year.
    I know for sure that I would no way be able to track down several pieces of information requested, such as names and addresses of schools that I attended (I attended quite a few, can’t remember the names of all of them, and I really doubt that all of them still exist).
    I don’t know what their criteria would be for selecting people to fill out this form, but I’m kind of thinking that being a naturalized citizen might well be one of them. Nonetheless, I’m wondering how they would justify needing this information, but only needing it from some people. On what grounds would they need it from some people but not others?
    I guess I’ll just need to hang on to my British passport…

    Reply
  117. imak

    Does this apply to renewing a passport? Or just getting it for the first time?

    Reply
  118. Chris

    Why is this country locking in citizens and not keeping out the crimanals? Look at all of the illegal aliens! Fuck its worse than I thought!

    Reply
  119. Robert Kent

    Whatever happened to We The People?
    Why do we need a passport to visit Canada? Don’t these assholes realize that terrorists won’t bother with border checkpoints? We have the largest undefended border in the world. There is no fence. It would be easy to take a mountain road across the border and nobody would ever know.
    So what’s the point?
    It’s time to vote these clowns out of office. Dump the passport requirements to visit Canada.

    Reply
  120. Amanda

    45 minutes? Some adoptees have spent 45 YEARS or more trying to get that information about themselves but can’t. Only 6 states allow Adult Adoptees unrestricted access to their birth certificates. 6 to 8 million people in the U.S. (the adopted) will likely not be able to meet the requirements on this form. I have my birth certificate and am reunited with my families but even I don’t know at least one of the questions asked and probably never will.

    Reply
  121. Robert

    Most people will make up sh** just to get through the ordeal. Like who in hell has all this information anyway? Maybe if your 12 years old you’ll have a handle on it. Who’s going to check your accuracy on all this nebulous crap? This is what happens when folks bought into all those lies about 911 being setup by 19 cave dwellers with box cutters. If you don’t question this staged event you will lose all your freedoms to tyrants. You will all end up like Perry3 on the first comment, a nitwit.

    Reply
  122. FROG

    If I fill out the form then I would assume that someone will have to verify the information. Well, if they can verify the information then they already have the information. Why do I have to take the time to fill out the form..Maybe they are using the same logic that justifies the felony arrest style of pat down of armed pilots before they can get on the plane to fly it. Or the groping of a six year old boy.
    “We are doing this to protect the citizens of this nation.”
    I do not find such declarations comforting.
    Is it just my imagination or is the water slowly getting warmer.

    Reply
  123. Dan

    45 Minutes?!?! Try 45 months of some private detective agency’s time. I lived in three different countries before college (and two of them before I turned seven), we probably moved every 3 years minimum during that time. I had numerous part-time jobs before and during college and I can barely remember WHAT the jobs were nevermind my “supervisor’s names and phone numbers”. I moved each year during college and grad school and have moved every 2-3 years since as jobs and circumstances changed. I’m lucky if I can name all the fucking CITIES I’ve lived in, never mind the addresses and zip codes. I’d like to meet the ass-wipe who came up with that “45 minutes” estimate, have him gather his extended family in a room and punch him in the balls for each minute over 45 minutes each person takes to get all that information. Maybe that’ll wake him up.

    Reply
  124. J. Cash

    I was born one mornin’ when the sun didn’t shine
    I picked up my shovel and I walked to the mine
    I loaded sixteen tons of number nine coal
    And the straw boss said “Well, a-bless my soul”

    Reply
  125. Chris

    I am a Canadian and really hope for the US’s sake, that does not go through. That’s ridiculous. But I do want to make a comment to the person who said that they should not need a passport to get into Canada. Just a bit of a history lesson–It was the US that implemented the passport for Canadians to visit the US, so Canada followed suit and made it a requirement for US citizens coming to Canada. I actually agree with needing passports for both sides. We all need to it to visit any other country so it does make sense. Hope this long form does get defeated!

    Reply
  126. Ramshackle

    1) When someone tells you that you must comply – do you always do it?
    2) Why is the reaction – finding someone to interject, who ‘deserves’ bad treatment more than you?
    3) Does it help bargaining with mom? Or Big Brother.
    There are reasons for some restrictions & requirements, but you have a right to know them.
    Obviously, if you cannot get this information, you are not a passport candidate! You will be doomed to living in some backwater corner of the U.S.
    Isn’t it odd – its about LEAVING the US & getting back in, as a citizen of this nation. Why would you leave the gated community at all?

    Reply
  127. Cliff Arroyo

    I was born in the wagon of a travelling show. My momma used to dance for the money they’d throw. Poppa would do whatever he could
    Preach a little gospel, sell a couple bottles of Doctor Good.
    “Gypsies, tramps and thieves!”, we’d hear it from the people of the town, they’d call us “Gypsies, tramps and thieves!” But every night all the men would come around … and lay their money down.

    Reply
  128. sansdollar

    Why on earth would our country need all that information if we are LEAVING the country? I think it is database building…LOL Phone numbers and as if we could remember names. Besides…who’s past employers are still in business? None of mine are, I can tell ya that for nothin’

    Reply
  129. Robin

    Read this article and I honestly had to shake my head at how retarded the US state department truelly is because do those morons really think that they can bully every citizen to fill out boring forms just to get a passport,especially when the supposed state department already has such info on record.They obviously must be so lazy that they can’t be bothered to look the information up on their computers,so they force every citizen out there to fill out these lame forms for nothing.I would say that this is a major waste of money

    Reply
  130. Kara

    that is a down right cruel questionnaire. If the government wants to require even one citizen to fill that out then they better fill it out themselves as well. It makes me wonder if even the President of the US had to submit that much info.

    Reply
  131. Jani P

    I hate to interrupt such a lovely sequence of senseless ranting, but the form in question is meant *only* for people who don’t have *any* of the following documents: an existing passport; a certified birth certificate; Consular Report of Birth Abroad or Certification of Birth; Naturalization Certificate; or Certificate of Citizenship. This means 99.99% of applicants will not need to fill this out… and the form makes life a little easier for the remaining 0.01% who currently have to battle with this: http://travel.state.gov/passport/get/secondary_evidence/secondary_evidence_4315.html

    Reply
  132. JohnGalt

    This form was designed by people who have only worked for the government their whole lives. How hard is it for them to tell you who has employed them?

    Reply
  133. Martin

    Building up a dossier on you for the coming US police state.

    Reply
  134. John

    @JaniP …. Shame on you for letting the facts get in the way of a good rant. I mean come on … Why should anyone have to actually prove they are a US citizen? We should give passports to anyone! Why would we want to question those people who have no proof that they are actually citizens?

    Reply
  135. michelle macey

    I am very distressed at the prospect of having to account for my whole life’s history just to get a passport to visit Canada for a 2 week vacation. I do not have a criminal record nor do I have any bad intentions to any creature or plant. However, accounting for all my life- long employment or lack thereof as well as all residenses (many of which I have forgotten the addresses) , I find disgusting. Now, not only am I sexually assaulted by TSA agents (my government at work) at the airport and forced to patronize fat-cat health insurance companies (no public optoion allowed) for just being born, now I need to offer a dossier for visiting Canada. Obama is just like Bush-maybe worse. To think I was stupid enough to vote for him.

    Reply
  136. Barry Soetoro

    Great to see what my so far unconstitutional president – acting double, today he names Barack Hussein Obama, will give to report.

    Reply
  137. john

    Jay Schmidt:
    You were doing fine until you got to Sarah…stupid she is not…

    Reply
  138. Dan Collins

    Perhaps they could provide us with a video of President Obama filling one out in 45 minutes. That would be inspiring.
    Until then, they can eff off.

    Reply
  139. David Parrish

    My mother informed me, many years ago, that she had counted 42 different homes that we had lived in across America between California and Michigan by the time I graduated from High School. She said she kept track of all of the addresses of those homes even though I myself have never seen her list. She passed away years ago. Since then, my lifestyle and my vocation has taken over 21 different countries around the world. Filling out the details this form would require would be a real challenge for me.

    Reply
  140. nam-vet6869

    27 years in the Army, and spent five years just traveling in my motor home. I have no idea what my address was everywhere I lived. This is an attempt t make it more difficult for us to leave the country. Russia built a fence, Obama just makes it impossible to get travel papers..

    Reply
  141. knockmeout

    Well knock me out with a feather. When I applied for US Citizenship i supplied all my travel info and original birth certificate, even though I had already submitted same when I emigrated. I am not the best at remembering anymore does this mean that I am now a person without a country? I think the messiah obama hussein does not want us to travel, only him and his annointed ones as we are causing jobs to be created and also causing global warming. O messiah fly Ryanair.

    Reply
  142. Terry Ott

    My mother lived on another planet in the year just prior to, and periodically after, my birth. She was in the US on an Earth Tour sponsored by Intergalactica Travel when I was conceived, and returned briefly to give birth nine months later.
    My father, by accounts of those present in the tavern when they met, did shots for a couple of hours and then left with mommy to conceive me. He had no permanent address and has not been seen since other than briefly at casinos where he would play bingo with older women wearing large diamonds and hold their hands briefly while kissing them before leaving. Records show he sometimes gave “Onthelam” as his home town. Reportedly, he took employment with gas stations for a few minutes in a time; he was what is known as a “Cash Register Cleaner”.
    I have been searching for mom and dad for a few decades, to no avail. But my next scheduled seance with Madame Giselle may produce more information, in which case I will provide what I learn via an amended Passport Application Form. In the meantime, is it OK to go to Columbia on business?

    Reply
  143. Nik

    Why does a US citizen have to fill out anything? You’re a citizen, you surely have the right to a passport – end of story. That’s the way it works in my country in any case. From Europe, N.

    Reply
  144. Semmes

    Welcome to the Police State sheep.

    Reply
  145. Alex H

    I was born when the stork stopped off at the cabbage patch for a midnight snack. Jesus, my guardian angel, and the 3 wise men were in attendance. My attending physician was Dr. Doolittle and my nurse was Florence Nightingale.

    Reply
  146. Joseph

    As an employee of a US Defense Dept. contractor, I can safely say that this is beyond absurd. You don’t have to provide this much information to obtain a Secret clearance…why on Earth should this be required for a friggin’ passport? Any citizen who can afford one and who doesn’t have any substantial criminal record should be able to obtain one, provided they can show proof of their identity.

    Reply
  147. Clint

    In a knee jerk reation to the percieved stupidity of our governmental bueracrats, I particulary enjoyed the comments by Dan (punch them in the balls..for every minute over 45). It is sad state of affairs when the prevailing sentinments regarding one’s government; and I don’t think I am alone, is one of fear, frustration and, doubt. The fear is that “they” will continue to ignore the larger issues which will lead us further into penury. The frustration is that “they” don’t seem to care. The fear is that we will continue to elect these assholes! The clarification provided by another comment, “this is only for people that don’t have any documentation” is a welcome addition to the conversation. It is important to know the facts before we all go off on our rants, as satisfying as they may be. The lack of inclusion of facts in our daily discourse has led us to this point in time. If you don’t understand the issues, there is really no chance of solving them. We need leaders that will speak plainly and, not try to manipulate our thinking for self serving purpose. Government should address issues to the greater good of the “people” not, the ruling class, special interests or, any other minority. The majority is so confused (read unwilling to do the necessary work to understand the issues) that it is impossible to reach any clear definition of the problems at hand. They are all obscured by rhetoric that is aligned to specific interests, rather than providing enlightened discourse. Many of the comments in this string are indicative of our willingness to react emotionally, without any clear understanding of the underlying facts. Kudos to Jani P. for doing the research but, I still want to punch them in the balls.

    Reply
  148. Henry

    Now that the deadline has passed, what we can do to stop this?

    Reply
  149. Tom Randall

    This is just obama stupid! Just
    more illuminti/ 33 degree freemason
    control for the NWO!

    Reply
  150. TedPearson

    This is the typical kind of B.S. the Administration has been doing all along. As usual, the Libtards here invoke conservatives as being the cause of it all.

    Reply
  151. Stephen Morgan

    I was born in Kenya to a single white mother who slept around…”ALOT”
    Like a large percentage of Blacks I don’t know who my daddy is.
    Most Socialists claim to be present at my birth which they claim was in both hospitals in Hawaii. (I believe my mother was there).
    So please request Organizing for America for all witness Names and Addresses. Their should be plenty.

    Reply
  152. John Mood

    It’s the same kind of crap the Nazi regime required of Jews who were trying to leave in the mid and late 1930’s. They had extensive forms to fill in, they were required to pay their taxes for this year AND the next year, full well knowing they would not be theree the next year, but they had to pay their taxes anyhow, or they would be denied exit visas. They were forced to pay out so much in taxes and port fees and were then robbed by the Nazi controlled banks, some felt liucky to leave after losing 90% of their accumulated wealth icluding their homes and properties. Some felt lucky they got out with the clothes on their backs. and would have left naked had they been required to.
    It’s headed toward the sort of socialist facism of that era. Maybe we should call mr. obama “herr schikelgruber”. for a nickname.
    Me, I already have a passport, and I hope I won’t get the “special form treatment” I am particularly disturbed by the requests for religious information about ceremonies around the time of your birth. Do they want to also know if a Doctor or Moyle performed your cicumcision or if you are or aren’t circumcised?
    It’s sounds awfully socialist/facist to me…
    Did this originate at the State Department of the United States or from “The Onion”?

    Reply
  153. pete Nagle

    The purpose of this is clearly to deny Americans an exit strategy from the coming eugenics program. FEMA camp or Australia ? are options your government don’t want you to have.
    This is not bureaucratic error it is autocratic terror !

    Reply
  154. Timothy-Allen Albertson

    Ah, the response of obama the oaf to demands for illegal immigration control: Make is more difficult on the citizen.

    Reply
  155. robertsgt40

    State Department trying to block all the exits? Didn’t have any problem allowing all the capital out. I’m guessing there’s a way around the “long form” for a passport. Probably a “fee” involved

    Reply
  156. PitifulPearl

    I was born in the front seat of a Dodge on a cold and wintry night.
    My birth certificate reads “born en route to hospital”.
    Three people in the car.
    Two of those people are dead, the one remaining doesn’t like me very much … I may have traumatized her making my grand entrance. She’s well beyond the age of being able to remember much, anyway.
    Section C would be for me. How rude.
    YOUR PAPERS, PLEASE!
    I allowed my passport to expire …. just shoot me now.
    lolz@bottom of form “PAPERWORK REDUCTION ACT STATEMENT”

    Reply
  157. Terry Hendricks

    All this information required of a president who cannot turn over a legitimate birth certificate (let alone collage, high school or elementary school grades or records). Plus, he (and his wife and entourage) can go anywhere in the world, as often as they feel necessary, on our tax dollars. What a deal the American citizen has given this man! Well, it’s not like many of us are going to afford traveling anywhere outside of the US, what with higher taxes and health care costs coming our way like a run away high-speed rail train.

    Reply
  158. Ron F

    Does that mean Obama will have to divulge his information if he travels outside the country?
    Only some idiot in the Obama administration would think up something so ridiculous for Americans.

    Reply
  159. Carol

    GEEESH – it’s easier than soup for an illegal to get into our country AND stay here AND collect benefits! We’re being held prisoners!!! Get real!!!!

    Reply
  160. Cheryl

    I was born in the back seat of a borrowed Cadillac on Route 66. My birth certificate lists under hospital “14 1/2 miles west of Chandler on Highway 66”. In attendance were my mother and father. I was then taken to a small hospital in nearby Chandler to be “checked over”.

    Reply
  161. CB

    Funny how the administration is pushing this when the President can’t be bothered to release HIS long-form birth certificate.

    Reply
  162. alex

    wow lots of racism and crazy in here.
    most of you don’t passports in the first place. hey, isn’t it against your sovereign citizen beliefs to have them anyway?
    the biographical information described sounds exactly like the requirements of a background check to obtain a security clearance for a federal job. buuuut I guess national security and better practices for securing the country is only a problem when we need to justify invading a country that did nothing to us, right?
    yeah, im sure obama personally ordered this so that there’ll be better information on the prisoners being sent to the camps on those high speed rail system he only wants to build to bankrupt america and get ppl to the ovens faster.
    you people are ridiculous.

    Reply
  163. Richard L. Kent, Esq.

    This is a proposed change to a form to be used when someone is claiming US citizenship but born abroad and has NEITHER his own birth certificate NOR a Registry of Foreign Birth with the US Consulate. It is intended to investigate claims of supposed US citizenship. It is NOT to be used by domestically borned US Citizens in the ordinary course of business. And whoever wrote this article knew that. So whoever wrote this article is a FRAKKING LIAR.
    Stop it. You’re only making the Conservative movement look stupid.

    Reply
  164. anymay

    Dear Alex is right, this is exactly what is required for a TS security clearance.
    However, as is usual with someone who sees racism in every utterance, he misses the point. This IS NOT about to getting a TS security clearance and to equate it with that is truly ridiculous. (ridiculous is one of Alex’s favorite words so I thought I’d use it to make him happy, after all he was so taken with his post that he posted it twice!).
    One wonders if ole Alex is a “sovereign citizen” or even what he thinks he means by that. Does he see scary people with crowns on their heads?
    But while wondering about Alex one must give him full credit for wanting the borders firmly closed…at least we think that is what he is espousing, altho it seems somewhat at odds when one views his other statements thru the spectrum of leftwing politics.
    Oh Alex re: ” justify invading a country that did nothing to us, right?” you shouldn’t speak so negatively about Libya, really! All we are doing is bombing a few meanies aren’t we? And who needs to ask a nasty ole Congress, or even your true leaders, the UN, to bless that?
    PS Alex, I realize you may be female, but I chose to use the English language as I learned it in grade school…back in those dark old days “he, his, and him” was used as a indicator of hu”man” kind.

    Reply
  165. Jonathan "JDOGG" Lederman

    I can’t remember what I did last week let alone where I worked 10 years ago. Whatever the state department ois smoking get me some. For me as a U.S. Citizen I find this requirement to be appalling. I give you my social security number that says can’t be used as ID and you use it as a tracking method. What is next microchipping everyone in The U.S. Can you say Fascism? Time to rise up America. My moniker is Jonathan “JDOGG”Lederman- The Voice of A Nation you can hear me on Monday Nights at http://www.blogtalkrasdio.com/thirdeyeradio1 from 7:30 PM – 8:30 PM.

    Reply
  166. Carmen Arn

    I was born at Carswell Air Force Base in Ft Worth, Texas
    I was too young to take down names, phone numbers and so forth and I am sure if my Mom were alive today I could ask her and she might remember…but doubt it! They gave her some medication. All she told me that she remembered was that my Dad was out playing baseball when I was being born, so she was mad at him. Oh yeah and she said I was free, but my brother was born at Harris Hospital and cost too much! She blamed me for her stretch marks, but I never knew how many there were. I hope you don’t need to know that.

    Reply
  167. Andrew L

    No, this is far more information than is required for a security clearance. The type of information required for a security clearance its the same for addresses and employment but only goes back 7 years for a secret clearance or 10 years for a top secret. You are also able to add an explanation for any information that you do not have complete details. In the event that you have than the required number of years of history it goes back to age 16. Nonetheless it took me about 3 hours to find all my history; luckily I had most of my tax records. For those of you criticizing this information, which won’t apply to most US citizens, have you tried to get a driverslicense recently under the Real ID program put in place during the Bush administration? You need like 4 different things including a copy of Birth Certificate.

    Reply
    • Patty

      Agreed. I’m being asked to go back either 10 years or “since graduating high school” on applications for other countries’ universities’ PhD programs, (The one that said “since high school graduation” I told to go to Hell in three languages…) depending on the country and the university. In the case of university applications, I can just keep trying till I find one that doesn’t ask for too much rubbish. In the case of a passport application from one’s county of birth so as to be able to GO to that other country in the first place – fortunately Canada isn’t the only country I can claim citizenship of.

      Reply
  168. Tess_Comments

    More bull.
    How about Actively and Agressively Enforcing Current US Immigration Laws.

    Reply
  169. DC Handgun Info

    “Please describe the circumstances of your birth including the names (as well as address and phone number, if available) of persons present or in attendance at your birth”
    First thought: I don’t know, I was only ZERO MINUTES OLD, you dumba**es! Several speculative answers come to mind: “God”, “my biological mother” (identity unknown; may be deceased), “doctors” (identity unknown), “anesthesiologists” (identity unknown).
    Second thought: First have all federal bureaucrats outside of State Department do this, with a 70 percent completion rate, and every State Department employee, and the sitting president (Obama: Name of father? Who knows? Place of birth? Who knows? Family name at birth? Who knows?)
    This is the worst intrusion into personal history ever DEMANDED by any government. It reminds me of the worst regimes of the 1930s!

    Reply
  170. Mortimer G. Tirebiter

    I was born in the backseat of a Greyhound bus, rolling down Highway 41.

    Reply
  171. Tig

    Wow, they should make it this hard to get food stamps and welfare.

    Reply
  172. Jennifer

    Damn fascist bastards. The only extra information they should need is if your identity is in question. Who attended your birth, where your mother lived before your birth, the circumstances of your birth, or a religious ceremony around the time of your birth have nothing to do with getting a passport. You don’t even need that information for a Top Secret clearance in this country, and I should know, I was an RM/IT in the Navy for over 12 years. Even if you can’t remember your old supervisor’s name and number, it isn’t held against you. It shouldn’t be held against you if you want a passport, which is a RIGHT not a privilege.

    Reply
  173. victoria_29

    Now that is an idea. Make them use this form to get food stamps, medicaid & welfare & the rolls would be cleaned off in 24 hours. That is a great idea. As for a passport, I have had one all my life & for some lucky reason have kept it current-that comment is aimed at the idiot that assumes that no one has a passport. This is ridiculous. Anyone should be able to present their CERTIFIED birth certificate, social security card & picture ID & get a passport. We just need to get all our kids & grandkids their passports while they are little-that will circumvent this silliness as long as they keep them current. LOL even I can remember where I was 4 yrs ago & who was there when my grandson was born.

    Reply
  174. bonobo

    Wow, this is insane. Who the heck is running the State Dept?
    Seriously, it looks like something the Wingnut TeaBagger syndicate would write…
    Haven’t we had enough Big Government Intrusions by the (EVIL) Republicans already?
    Sheesh.

    Reply
  175. Joanna Watkins

    If he made it this hard to get into this country, we wouldn’t be in such a financial mess. What ever happened to the privacy act? What ever happened to a lot of things.
    I want my money back!!!!

    Reply
  176. hiway280z

    Before long Americans will tie logs together or jump on boatstotry to escape in the dark to leave this Marxist country under Obama

    Reply
  177. hiway280z

    Can’t profile so it will be little old ladies or little children they grope before they can fly.
    Federal Police state

    Reply
  178. John

    If Tyranny and Oppression come to this land, it will be in the guise of fighting a foreign enemy.
    — James Madison

    Reply
  179. Skeptical

    Somebody please prove that the form posted is actually from the State Dept. and not something made up intended to scare

    Reply
  180. ileneg

    What will Obama do?

    Reply
  181. Justin N

    As detailed on my blog, this is an update to an EXISTING FORM. My wife received one when she applied for a passport, and yes, it took hours to get the necessary data. The reason she had to fill out the info? Apparently, because people who apply with a state ID card and not a driver’s license are suspicious. Her passport was eventually issued.
    I should note that she applied for a passport under the Bush administration.

    Reply
  182. Linda Bluesky

    What a bunch of tools you people are! Anything to bash the prez, right? Did any of you read the comment from the attorney who posted above? This is yet another thing to get the right’s panties in a bunch, which is so easy to do! Be afraid, it’s workin’ for ya so far!
    Tools!

    Reply
  183. Fran

    I am Caucasian, American born 65 y.o. female tax paying registered nurse…. 4 years ago I had to produce over 40 documents to get my passport. If anything this document could make it easier to get something that I had to fight for. I agree on the B.S. I also think this could make it easier for illegals to get a passport.

    Reply
  184. Kawfeee

    I dont know why Americans would want a passport. Escape strategy? yeah right! where you gonna go? Everybody hates your guts. If you have money they might let you in. but when the gold id gone, so are you. payback time! You asked for it… and deserve it.. Border patrol, with their expertise, might be able to get a job in Mexico..

    Reply
  185. Todd Beck

    MY ANSWER: “I was born at a very young age, although my memory is a little iffy on details. There was a bathtub. And a screaming woman. And my mother. I don’t have my mother’s address or phone number because we haven’t spoken in 27 years. The screaming woman was named Fran, and my mother found her via an ad on Craig’slist for a midwife. So check http://www.craigslist.com and search for Fran. Or Alice, because later I heard she changed her name to move up in the alphanumeric listing.”

    Reply
  186. whowouldjesusbomb

    What makes you people think that OBAMA is behind this? If you think this is some ‘liberal’ scheme, you haven’t been paying attention to what’s been happening for the last ten years. The last fifty, for that matter. This is not coming from a partisan agenda. It’s coming from the globalist, one-world, impoverish-everyone, control-everything agenda of a small group of powerful evil people.
    Obama is a stealth neocon. Wake up. You can’t name one ‘liberal’ thing he’s done because he hasn’t done any. the insurance reform is just another financial scam. so is carbon trading.

    Reply
  187. fed-up

    The fact that there is even a consideration of something like this, when our government is bending over and allowing illegal aliens to have access to benefits that are funded by our tax dollars is disgusting!
    And the person who wants this form to only be applied to “birthers” should really get a clue – while I am NOT a “birther”, the difference is the criteria. The criteria for being President of the US is that one must be a natural born citizen. There are some people who believe that there is a legitimate question as to whether our current president meets that criteria. What difference does all of the miscellaneous and extraneous information contained in this form make regarding obtaining a passport?
    It’s really a shame that our current government has divided our country to the point that it has. There is so much hatred that I fear where we might be headed.

    Reply
  188. richard wagener

    I was in a hurry to leave the house to get to the post office to renew my passport, before it closed. I couldn’t find my old one so I just went to get it figuring since I already had one’ I could probably just use my driver’s license. I stepped up to the counter and told the guy what I wanted. He said he was sorry, but he had to see my birth certificate before he could give me one. Since there were other people there I put my hand by the side of my mouth, and said just loud enough for him to hear,”I wonder how Obama got his?” Then I left.

    Reply
  189. Daniel Latta

    I was concerned about this article until I read these comments. You people are lunatics.

    Reply
  190. Superinfidel

    Employment history? Schools? Residences? They want DATES??? I’m 60 years old, 1/4 Gypsy and 1/4 Cherokee with a family history of Alzheimer’s. I have ALOT of history, for Pete’s sake, much of which I cannot remember.

    Reply
  191. TexasMom

    We will never have another Free election again. This is Zimbabwe. This is Castro’s Cuba.
    Like the one comment above, in a few more months we will be trying to get the hell out of here – and like the stupid sheeple we are, will try legal means and this passport will keep us trapped in this Marxist hell. So we will next make a run for where? Canada? The Cubans were lucky – they had America just 90 miles away. Read “Waiting for Snow in Havana” – we’re experiencing the same thing here. A Marxist redistribution of wealth. Everybody here will be living in a turde-world nightware, “to each according to his need”. We created much of this with government meddling. Welfare is evil. People forced into dependency, crawling as supplicants for bare sustenance. The MSWs got good salaries for playing nannie. So now we’re all going to be stripped naked and taught to beg for a sip off the government teat. Fools. All. Maybe something was put in the water to shrivle men’s cajones or we wouldn’t be in this mess. Not with real MEN around. This fool would not be sitting in the White House. Yes, a lot of black persons know this. If you are working and independent, you are considered “rich”. That’s why I am sitting out this year, 2011. If I don’t make it, they can’t take it.

    Reply
  192. Christian Lipski

    “It’s sounds awfully socialist/facist to me…”
    Ha ha ha ha ha.
    Words have meanings, you know.

    Reply
  193. pasjr

    Think about it people! Think. Read the form again and maybe it will come to you. It’s not rocket science!

    Reply
  194. AZ sandman

    This would mean obama would have to cough up his identity info. He won’t be President for ever (I hope).

    Reply
  195. Lorbee

    @Alex. Isn’t “you people” considered racist?

    Reply
  196. Lorbee

    How can those questions be valid? Who could possibly check them as factual? Your mother’s address a year before you were born…huh? Oh–and does my baptism count as a religious event surrounding my birth? I can’t stand what is happening in this world on a daily basis, truly.

    Reply
  197. Terri P.

    This looks like what my son (he is a U.S. Marine) had to fill out in order to get his current security clearance. I spent one full day (7 hours) on the phone with him, in order to help him get all the paperwork done. He was 21 at the time. What do people do that have no living relatives that can give them the answers?

    Reply
    • Patty

      We don’t get passports, that’s what.
      As you can see, this leaves the doors wide open for bona fide US citizens to resort to looking on the black market to BUY passports. It’s requirements like these for real ones that are the reason so many counterfeit and fake ones abound.

      Reply
  198. dave

    Don’t tie yourselves in knots everybody; this is not a prelude to Nazism or Soviet era tyranny. The ruling guideline for the State Department when issuing passports simply amounts to this: Are you who you say you are? If you cannot supply a birth certificate then this new form, DS-5513, amounts to nothing more than an bureaucratic alternative to determine one’s citizenship. What with identity theft a global criminal concern nowadays, it hardly seems unreasonable for State to have this form in place as a deterrent. Moreover, if you cannot answer some of these questions it is nowhere indicated that you will be denied a passport only that it may– I repeat, may result in a denial. Is State being intrusive and clumsy in their intents? Yes. Is there any better or less invasive way to go about this? Probably not, and not satisfy everybody. But, however much we may disapprove of the govt’s strategy, that is certainly no reason to jump to what I would submit is an unwarranted conclusion that there is a conspiracy afoot.
    State is just another bump and prick we have to put up with.

    Reply
  199. Emily

    This looks like another one of those Far-Right website.. Poor babies are either crying or blaming Obama for everything that goes wrong in the world!

    Reply
  200. AlanD

    I only saw your article on April 26, so cannot comment to State. How many US citizens knew about this ridiculous, totally unreasonable proposal?
    For anyone born in the USA, the state in which they were born is the one to decide the procedure for filing and then issuing a delayed birth certificate, not Washington DC. Or does the State Dept. forget that we still are a federal republic? If Texas, for one, is loose in issuing birth certificates to those claiming births years before in Texas, then the Federal Government should sue to restrain Texas from issuing such certificates based on delayed findings.

    Reply
  201. Hooper

    Is this for real? Can this be possible? who would think up something like this…I can understand trying to keep people OUT of the USA..but not let us OUT? Do they know something that we don’t? Is something going to happen that is so large and so dramatic that they want to lock us IN?
    Why would it matter where my mother lived a year before I was born or a year after. Who cares what work I did when I was a teenager? Do they think I would even remember the name of my supervisor and a phone number from 40 or 50 years ago? I can’t even remember what I did 10 minutes ago.

    Reply
  202. Leah

    Hate to break it to you, but you are dead wrong Richard Kent Esq.. My 18 year old son just applied for his third U.S. Passport and provided them with a live original birth certificate, but because he wasn’t born in a medical facility, he must provide additional documentation. He was free U.S. Citizen and now he is he is waiting for them to grant him his citizenship again, if he provides them with what they want. Richard L. Kent, Esq.wrote: This is a proposed change to a form to be used when someone is claiming US citizenship but born abroad and has NEITHER his own birth certificate NOR a Registry of Foreign Birth with the US Consulate. It is intended to investigate claims of supposed US citizenship. It is NOT to be used by domestically borned US Citizens in the ordinary course of business. And whoever wrote this article knew that. So whoever wrote this article is a FRAKKING LIAR.
    Stop it. You’re only making the Conservative movement look stupid.

    Reply
    • Patty

      What one does when one is born abroad to an Irish citizen is to first register oneself with their Ministry of Foreign Births or whatever. THEN one goes for the Passport. But the Irish passport forms make this perfectly clear. And they’re in the same language as the US one, I think. (??) Once you’ve registered yourself with the foreign birth abroad ministry, you supposedly have already submitted all those necessary documents, so I’m wondering what the hell is wrong with THIS country’s version of the English language?

      Reply
  203. sodacrackers2

    Surely this was written on April 1? Is there a new federal agency in charge of “Every Day a New Atrocity?” Why would the government need all this information to let us leave the country when they allow thousands of illegals to enter, work in, be schooled, collect all benefits in our country daily without so much as a “how do you do?”

    Reply
    • Patty

      Agreed!! It’s one thing if the Embassies abroad are doing this nonsense because, after all, they’re in charge of basically letting you back IN. But, to LEAVE?? Wait, now all of a sudden I get why the Irish and French consulates abroad are doing their version of this – but in their case it’s not THIS bad yet. So far it’s just “proof of residence.” I hear the UK one is also pretty nasty, though.

      Reply
  204. greg

    just put in false dates, names, places etc cause they don’t have the time or money to verify.

    Reply
    • Patty

      That’s about what it boils down to, with the “proof of address” that is the bare-minimum of this nonsense that the French and Irish embassies require of theirs. As if the French Consulate abroad can “verify” your bank statement…especially if you want to come pick the foul thing up IN PERSON so they don’t even HAVE to mail it to you.

      Reply
  205. You Wouldn't Care

    Christian Lipski April 26, 2011 at 6:41 pm
    “It’s sounds awfully socialist/facist to me…”
    Ha ha ha ha ha.
    Words have meanings, you know.
    —-@Christian
    “socialist/fascist” is a construct of 2 words. What do the meanings have in common? Both systems are TOTALITARIAN.
    It’s simple…
    Don’t be sophomoric to be critical, please.
    The world’s overloaded with critics. Seek truth. Promote solutions.

    Reply
  206. Chrispy

    I guess President Obama won’t be going anywhere outside the USA for the rest of his life. That’s good for us since he is such an embarrassment to the country.

    Reply
  207. justin Jest

    Leah
    You are the one joking right. Please say yes. Applying for a THIRD passport and having to provide extra documentation?
    We make China look sensible.

    Reply
  208. alej g

    A strict reading of this new document would mean that I have to supply the names and phone numbers of all the hospital nurses and doctors that helped in the delivery of my kids. I had rather lengthy deliveries and there were shift changes! OMG! Absurd doesn’t begin to cover it. Who was paid to think this up?

    Reply
  209. JC

    If every employee at the State Dept. can successfully fill out one of these applications, then and only then, would I go along with it.

    Reply
    • Patty

      Nonsense, US Federal government employees would NEVER make themselves fill out that dastardly form. Now, on the other hand: you should see the hellish forms you have to have filled out to get THAT job. (Their own passports are “diplomatic” ones, I think…from back when I briefly worked for INS before it became “Homeland Security.”)

      Reply
  210. Jeff

    I sprang forth from my mother’s loins, grabbed a top hat and marched up and down the hospital hall singing a jaunty rendition of “Hello My Baby, Hello My Darlin’, Hello My Ragtime Gal” in a mad tribute to Michigan J. Frog!

    Reply
  211. rackfocus

    Donald Trump was present at my birth, therefore I need not answer any other questions. He is the ultimate power when it comes to these sorts of issues.

    Reply
  212. LTVigil

    @Leah;
    I downloaded the PDF of the proposed form and it says pretty clearly at the top: “Biographical Questionnaire For A U.S. Passport”…seems to apply to anybody who wants to travel outside the country.

    Reply
  213. kiwicris

    I just bought this article to my wifes attention She does not belive that it is a genuine state dept doco. “for what purpose would they make you get details of your pre and post natal doctors appointments, etc etc. that it was probably a made up thing . . . i said i thought they had made it so difficult so to cut down on the number of people wanting to flee the usa before it falls over from spiralling debt. surely this is not ment to be used for every passport applicant. . .

    Reply
  214. Preppergal

    All these questions about birth and the mother’s address, etc…..so does that mean that passports will be denied to all adoptees? Many don’t even have original birth certificates. The state issuing and listed on the birth certificate doesn’t necessarily match up with where the adopted parents lived.

    Reply
    • Patty

      I’ve met some adoptees who said they had extremely difficult times getting a passport….so, in short, YES. Now, that was in the USA. In Canada, I’ve met an adoptee who DOES have a Canadian passport. He was born, allegedly according to him, in Venezuela, adopted in the Philippines, and now has a Canadian passport. That is the easiest way to get a Canadian passport – NOT be born there.

      Reply
  215. Suzanne Rosenorn

    Lawmakers would rather screw around making it harder for its citizens than to address the real issues pressing like illegal aliens. There has been many presidential administrations from either party that have allowed millions to sneak in this country for decades. Is this passport thing a weak attempt to try to show they are interested in controlling immigrants? I dont think so.

    Reply
  216. Tim

    This reminds me of the completely assinine, totally invasive “mandatory” questionaire we received in the mail from the US Chamber of Commerce. It was in addition to and supposedly a part of the US Census survey though it came separately. It’s called the American Community Survery. Google that. The questions were ludicrious. For example how many times a day do we go to the bathroom. OK what it asked was how many times a day do you flush the toilet. Same thing. And a lot of very personal financial and family information.
    If you refuse to answer, and a lot of people consider it, they let you know that there is a $5,000 fine if you do. If to avoid the fine you answer it but they feel that you are not being completely honest it’s a $200 for every “false” answer. No kidding. I mean, what is this, the Soviet Union? Why is it that we are being conditioned via many avenues to accept the idea of no privacy at all. Ever since Bush and the Patriot Act things have just gotten over-the-top ridiculous. It’s like “we own you”.

    Reply
  217. TErry

    Who in the world is going to remember all the information they are asking. How in the world are you going to remember every that is being asked on that questionnaire; i.e., a phone number of a supervisor and his phone from years ago. He is probably dead and the phone is out of service. How ridiculous is this government getting. Sounds more communistic. Why do they want to keep from leaving the country?

    Reply
  218. ole Bob

    I will fill in the form if President Obama does the same.

    Reply
  219. Kirsty

    Does this apply to those who are renewing their passport as well? (sorry if its been asked before)

    Reply
    • Patty

      Probably.

      Reply
  220. Ayac

    I just had to go for the extra points: I was born in a village by the sea in Alaska. Hahaha: phone numbers of who present? In Alaska. Many years ago…
    Still, obtaining passports aren’t difficult, some postal clerks seem to have a running efficiency of passport requirements.

    Reply
  221. Eric

    We’re so… free.

    Reply
  222. Cosmic Debris

    There’s going to be a boom in demand for information about dead doctors, defunct businesses, former residential areas that are now strip malls. If you have foreign passports, keep them up to date.

    Reply
    • Patty

      Doesn’t help much. Like I’ve already said, Canada’s application is just as bad if not worse and it’s been that way since it changed in 2004. The UK, France and Ireland have started requiring “proof of address” even if you intend to pick the foul thing up IN PERSON. Oh, other countries are GETTING THERE, never fear.

      Reply
  223. HRT

    On the day of my birth, back in the day, it was a Friday, from my recollections the day started early, with a lot of loud noises and bright lights. There was at least one doctor there and a woman that I had never seen before, I was told later that the woman was to be called “Mommy” and the man with the cigar was to be referred to as “Dad” aka “Daddy”. Granted my memories are kinda fuzzy at this point and I’m pretty sure anything I remember would be heresay but apparently there may or may not have been flowers and/or balloons involved. Because it was the 70’s polyesther was quite prevalent, as was copious amounts of a strange (at the time) white beverage, some people call it milk. It was a strange day indeed.

    Reply
  224. TexasMom

    Consider this. Some Jews escaped Germany when things began to look bad. Some tried to warn others and were ridiculed or made to feel that they were insanely paranoid. And look what happened to MILLIONS OF HUMAN BEINGS…..all because people like to live in their comfortable little mindsets and deny something so horrible could happen.
    That’s what is happening now. Our media labels persons who KNOW something is terribly wrong here – they are called “right wing” or “birthers” or “insane”. Some of us are going to survive these times but it will be the ones who are field-independent!
    We deny the dark side of human nature, OR that as Americans we were the target for ENVY all over the world. Don’t say Obama/Barry/Steve didn’t warn you before the 2008 election. Remember? He said the rest of the world didn’t like our lifestyle and comforts.
    This government is failing fast. They cannot pay their obligations, such as Social Security. By eliminating some of the recipients they eliminate this “problem”.
    The sad fact is people had no option – workers all had to pay Social Security taxes and later, Medicare taxes. Now they are holding one-way tickets to the “social security Final Solution”. ….how to kill them? Run up gasoline costs travel and utilities.. “Food Safety” to make us all Kulacks, unable to grow our own food “Codex Alimentarious” to deny access to vitamins/supplements, “Obama-care” with higher and higher premiums deducted from older persons, “End of Life counseling” to make them feel guilty for being alive and make nobility in euthanisia.
    HEAD FOR THE HILLS FOLKS – IT’S OPEN SEASON ON AMERICANS!!!

    Reply
  225. BO Madness

    While we are debating this issue, please do not forget we voted for “change” !!!!

    Reply
  226. Hannah

    According to my father, who works for the State Dept, they are using that form only for applicants that cannot produce conventional proof that they are American citizens (e.g., a birth certificate, naturalization certificate, or previous US passport). This is irregardless of where you were born; it is simply for people who do not have the other typical documentation.
    Please PLEASE make sure you have all the facts before you scare people like this.

    Reply
    • Patty

      If this is true, then that’s nice to know. Consider yourselves lucky, AmeriKKKa. Canada’s form looks like that already; as of 2004 when they first decided to make it multiple-pages with directions to account for every place you’d been and every job you’d had for the past 10 years (as of 2004. By now it’s probably gotten much, much worse.)

      Reply
  227. Toby

    Well, I corrected the misspelling of “atrocious” first.

    Reply
  228. edutron

    The United Staes Gov is in fear that U.S. citizens will discover that there are better places to live other than the United States (true story). This proposal is directed at the middle class and poor working class only as those with money have their lawyers draw up a passport app. in minutes. Heaven forbid if the working class (skilled) work elsewhere and donate their taxes to another country since the U.S. Gov squanders your tax dollars without notice and at every whim.

    Reply
  229. Tiffany

    I think this form should be required for anyone wanting to run for a Federal public office!

    Reply
  230. callofthewild

    This proposal seems to mean that once the illegals get in the USA they can’t get out again. Hmmmm suppose it is because so many aliens tend to work really hard for their money, many hours every day and once they are actually paying taxes, Uncle Sam doesn’t want them to leave? Receivers of SSI and SS don’t pay taxes…. so naturally we gotta have new blood to drain…. maybe illegal traffic across the southern border will now slow down at the anticipation of getting stuck here forever.

    Reply
  231. D S

    INCREDIBLE! Absolutely nobody knows the names and addresses of the people attending their birth with possibly the exception of the physician unless they were delivered in an at-home birth. Why would anyone need to know if a mother had pre- or post-natal care in order to allow them to travel? What does circumcision or lack thereof have to do with traveling anywhere? Will this be a new inspection step for males going through the airport security line? Whoever is coming up with this stuff does not have enough useful work to do at their job and they have pretty twisted minds. Who can remember the addresses of every place they have ever lived? These kind of things are examples of how government wastes taxpayer $ at the best. At worst, it is invasion of privacy of citizens. Americans abhor “Big Brother” tactics and should loudly and insistently condemn and oppose them.

    Reply
  232. Hapgood

    I just had a look at Obama’s birth certificated, as posted on numerous media outlets. The interesting thing is that some of the information requested on the form (attending physician at birth, mother’s address and occupation) is on the birth certificate. So it seems there is some rationale for collecting at least some of it when there isn’t an official birth certificate showing birth in a hospital.
    The only problem is the additional level of detail and the difficulty nearly everyone would have in obtaining or reconstructing it after decades. And it still doesn’t explain the need for every address since birth (including Zip code), and every employer since birth (including supervisor’s name and phone number). I’m also not sure about claims that it would be restricted to only a few people who lack an acceptable official birth certificate. The Federal Register filing provides no hint of who would be subject to this form.
    The real problem is the complete disconnect between the officials who most likely are well-intentioned and the people who have to fill in the form. Their claim that it could be completed in 45 minutes shows that disconnect. And the lack of clarity about who will be requested to provide the information only encourages speculation that it could be abused to arbitrarily deny passports to people disliked by some State Department or DHS official.

    Reply
  233. Dai

    Assuming this is not a giant prank: The circumstances of my birth are a bit murky. I got the story from my adoptive sisters.
    It seems that my mother worked as a Downstairs Maid in a wealthy household. One day, she was lured Upstairs by the Son of the House – who immediately impregnated her. Since, pregnant servants were not allowed, she was fired. Nine months later, I turned up on the Church Steps. The good Sisters of Mercy then took care of me until I was adopted, 2 – 4 years later (it’s a bit hazy)
    My adopters were a lovely coal mining family and I had a great childhood running around the mountains of Wales. I married & had kids and, one day, got a job in New York. After 20 or so years I became a citizen. I am now 72 years old.
    Very little of that is verifiable. However, my saviour will be the Sisters of Mercy. I mean, who wouldn’t believe them – good Anglican Nuns? If I can only track them down….

    Reply
  234. Ed Largy

    The Illuminati’s NWO New World Order has to contain people where they are and will not allow them to move about freely. This is all about CONTROLLING the world herd so that they can keep tabs on them. Only the privileged people trusted by the NWO leaders will be given free access to move at will if it serves their purpose. This is not surprising that the State Dept. is making it extremely difficult to get a passport. They are also harassing people at the airports by excessive bodily checks on children, woman, etc. Also delaying planes now, keeping people cooped up under hot conditions waiting over hours before taking off, using lame excuses or no excuses for doing this. All in all, travel will be controlled by our dear controllers controlling our govt. in Amerika.

    Reply
  235. Toby

    For some reason my earlier attempt to post this at 11:29 today did not go through.
    In spite of deadline date, I sent my comments via the email addy in the article – [email protected]
    Document ID: DOS-2011-0055-0001

    Reply
  236. Provacateur

    The people who will have to answer this questionnaire are the same people who, based on the facts of their case and in order to prove citizenship for the purposes of a passport, will need to complete a long supplementary interview and processing and submission of documents covering most of this info anyhow.
    Cases which present these kinds of problems can be even LESS efficient without the data pre-gathered in a neat format, which this form provides. Relax, people.

    Reply
    • Patty

      You mean, people not BORN in the USA? In Canada it’s the opposite – if you WERE born there, you get grilled even MORE. I got called an “impostor” and a “fraud” right in front of my face by the social insurance office in Montreal and told I was “a foreigner from overseas” instead of someone BORN THERE. It took me TWO TRIES to get my social insurance card. And I had a run-in with Human Rights Canada in the meantime, reporting them. I should have reported Canada to the UN commission on human rights for human rights violations. As an “Aboriginal” First Nations, I can tell you it’s even WORSE when you’re a Native aboriginal person of either of these two countries. They’re supposed to BACK OFF the grilling when we say that part, but instead they keep it up anyway – and that’s a Treaty violation. I remember one time when crossing the border into New York in a car, being told we were First Nations (all three of us in the car: me Choctaw, driver Cherokee, and front passenger Cree) that did stop some of the million questions that US Border Patrol is famous for — at least they did seem to have an inkling of the meaning of the term “Treaty rights.”
      And dealing with Passport Canada is even worse, or so I hear. I was only BORN there – I would never try for a Passport. Instead I use the passports of countries my parents or grandparents were born in. (But these days even Ireland and France are cracking down – wanting proof of address and all)

      Reply
  237. Gil

    Chrispy – that was not a logical comment at all. Obama is far from an embarrassment to our country. On the global stage, our country finally has credibility and acknowledgment for placing an intellectual person in the White House, not some wild cowboy taking us down the rabbit hole. I love how Tea Party Radio Republicans scream socialism and fascism – take one look at the Patriot Act and there is your Orwellian nightmare of socialism & fascism come alive. Worse than any healthcare bill is the degradation of your rights. You weren’t crying when that was passed. A society that gives up its liberty for some false sense of security deserves neither.
    On the passport note, let’s all hold our collective breaths and wait to see what shakes loose from this. It sounds like jockeying for position by someone – ask for the stars, and see if you can just hit the moon.

    Reply
  238. JJ Flash

    I was born in a cross-fire hurricane
    And I howled at my ma in the driving rain
    I was raised by a toothless, bearded hag
    I was schooled with a strap right across my back

    Reply
  239. wataloadofcrap

    Looks like they want to keep us in the states for some reason, get ready people, sh1t’s going to hit the fan real soon and they don’t want us to get away.

    Reply
  240. FloridaBorn

    I just saw this article. It was a link from a friend’s Facebook wall. I still sent a comment. The proposed form would be a lot like filling out an application for SSDI. That took me over 3 weeks to fill out on-line.
    I was born so long ago that the names of the people who were there would require a pharmacist to transcribe the handwriting. Were the attending physician alive he would be over100 years old. And my former employers? At least 2 of my former employers are dead, so their phone numbers wouldn’t do the government any good. Why isn’t the money for this preposterous form being used to keep illegals OUT instead of trying to prevent legal US residents from leaving the country?

    Reply
  241. Trisha Springstead

    My Father was in the Military and I went to get this 14 different schools by the time I graduated high school. Oh I’ll get right on this detail. This is 1984 by Huxley, Oh and about the Holicaust, we’ve already been gassed her on the Gulf, its called CORE-EXIT.
    People are dying from that crap they sprayed in the water and on the people of the Gulf. Who need Gas Chambers we have the Oil Companies.

    Reply
  242. John N Florida

    Bizarre. Only a Bureaucrat could come up with this.

    Reply
  243. retired in texas

    I would like to comment to “Callofthe wild”. Fisrt of all; retired people collecting SS DO PAY TAXES on the money they recieve!!! By the way the GOVERNMENT DOES NOT contribute one penny to the fund. I have worked for 50 years of my life and should be able to enjoy what my EMPLOYER and I were taxed for this fumd. As for this passport application, the questions are invasive. By the way, my family have been on US soil since 1667 in what is still Maryland.

    Reply
  244. William

    This really does not surprise me. Control the food supplies, control the water supplies, and control travel, do that long enough and you control the whole country. so to be the whole world. Almost half of the water supply is polluted, I have read report that in south America you can’t even dig a well all water is owned by corporations,..Over 80% of the food supplies is corrupted by GMO’s or other chemicals that are killing us oh so slowly.. Our air we breath is well, not much to be desired. Because of the big melt down of all the ice packs and glaciers the water levels are rising and the storms are in creasing in deadliness. Ah yes another greenie spouting off his sepal.. May so, but I wonder, these are god given facts.. undisputed facts..—shrug— Oh well… see you around boys and girls.. But don’t be looking for food hand outs from me.. Or water for that mater..

    Reply
  245. Bob

    “America is at that awkward stage. It’s too late to work within the system, but too early to shoot the bastards.” – Claire Wolfe

    Reply
  246. Jim Bee

    I was adopted
    I’m now 63 yrs old
    I dont even know my brothers or sisters.
    Im white – 6ft 2in. – 259lbs.
    I was adopted only because the farmer in Washington state
    need more slaves to work his farm.
    I was beaten regularly for not bring in enough wood for the stove or not feeding the cow’s, hog’s, chickens enough feed.
    All I want to do is drive to Alaska again before I die.

    Reply
  247. Mac

    This is taking things to far, it’s stupid that us Canadians need a passport to cross the border, as it makes a huge hassle, and is frustrating. On top of that they want to know everything about you and your family, and sometimes these are questions you cannot answer. Is that right? No I do not think so. It is a direct invasion of privacy, makes me wonder if they have some sort of idea that isn’t moral. Perhaps weeding out?… To gain the money they should have held onto perhaps? Whatever their reasoning I believe they are so wrong.

    Reply
    • Patty

      I’m Canadian, but I’m covered by the Jay Treaty so I didn’t require a Canadian passport to go back and forth across the border BY LAND. By air, yes. In a car, no. But that’s “an Indian thing.” Doesn’t apply to non-Indians.

      Reply
  248. charlie

    And yet, illegal alians can VOTE! ‘doesn’t make sense.

    Reply
  249. David

    In order to receive my current passport I had to answer these questions. I was originally denied a passport card last year, and earlier this year they denied my passport book application unless I had completed an exhaustive questionnaire of my life history from the date of my birth.
    I was shocked and appalled that I had to provide this list considering I had been issued a passport in 1990 without any problems. I originally thought this ridiculous protocol was due to the fact my original passport had been lost and I could not return it to the State Department, I did receive my passport; however, the overall process took almost 3 months.
    It looks as that “Iron Curtain” is being lowered in the United States, make me so sad that our freedoms continue to erorde on a daily basis.

    Reply
    • Patty

      This is precisely why people are needing passports. So they can LEAVE. And in some cases, find a JOB. Now mind you, how one is supposed to go about doing that in another country with a US passport, I’ll never know – most other countries won’t hire Americans to do anything even if they’re stratospherically overqualified.

      Reply
  250. Beanlet

    One way that Obama could make it easy for illegal aliens to get US passports is to cause good citizens to be angry enough to cancel all verifications for a passport. Why else would they threaten us with such ridiculous measures? (For a passport you have to prove you are a citizen, but it is an invasion of privacy to have to give the government a diary of your life.)

    Reply
  251. Littlejoenc

    You Can Check In But You Can Never Leave

    Reply
  252. Baldur

    How long before that border fence is keeping American citizens *inside* the U.S.?

    Reply
  253. bill

    The last thing the US government wants is citizens leaving the country and discovering how the rest of the world perceives us…or how much better citizens in many other countries are treated. Keep Americans Ignorant – something both parties can vote for.

    Reply
  254. damefrank

    Once upon a time….our forefathers were illegal immigrants. U.S. natural resources belong to other countries. What part of these borders are we protecting and why? If welfare is the issue, why doesn’t Obama retract Bush’s cut-back on claiming full deductions for contributions to non-profits? Non-profits provided valuable social services that did not stem from the taxpayers pocketbook and made this country more humanitarian and giving.

    Reply
  255. Butch Kendrick

    Your new form for obtaining a passport is way out of line. This will obviously put a burden on the honest citizens of the US and do very little to avoid providing passports to those who should be denied. You tell me what the address is of the first place you ever worked or the other personal information about your family that has no relation to your application for a passport. Your laws are out of hand and misguided to the point that they have lost all credibility. Remember what it is to be a citizen and think about how this would affect you and stop the march to total control.

    Reply
    • Patty

      Spot on. Unfortunately AmeriKKKa isn’t the only country to start doing this kind of rubbish. Canada’s is already 4 pages long and wants you to account for your whereabout for the past 10 years, and if you can’t get 2 “references” to vouch for you then you have an additional 5 pages’ worth of verification to come up with and 5 MORE referees. A lot of people born in Canada can’t get Canadian passports through all of this rubbish. Canada needs to be taken to the UN Human Rights Commission on charges or something…

      Reply
  256. Peter Allen

    I agree, let’s DO IT! It would be interesting to see how Obama fills his out, especially his address at birth, and the religious question. But I’m just dreaming I guess… why would he be any more honest to a form than face-to-face to the public. Why is that you suppose? Is he embarrassed by his religion? Believes that it’s fundamentally wrong? Or is it just a matter of being “one of the guys” so as to garner more votes?
    pwallen1962

    Reply
  257. rosalind freed

    Americans…..your Government is building a Berlin Wall to keep you in. if you can’t get a passport, you are a prisoner.
    I’m a Brit living in Mexico, having lived 18 years in the US, I love America the Land of the Free……but it’s not anymore.
    Mexico is a wonderful place to live, 1/2 the cost of living of the US, delightful people, definitely a 1st world country and I have traveled widely and spent the last 4 years in Costa Rica which is in no way comparable to Mexico. There is no danger, no crime, just don’t do drugs and you’ll be fine. Your Government and the press are lying to you! Retirees…..refugee to Mexico while you still can!
    The US can’t afford for citizens to leave with their money and their incomes, now they’ve found a new way to close the borders, with paperwork!

    Reply
  258. vivian caramanna

    close the borders to keep illegals out. not Americans in.

    Reply
  259. nespinosa

    1. Who is going to verify that the infor provided is true and accurate?
    2. How much is it going to cost the taxpayers for the salaries of what I’m sure would be a very large agency estalished to oversee this?
    3. How does this help our current immigration problem?
    4. What idiot sits around and thinks up these ideas?

    Reply
  260. Betty Grossweiler

    This is no longer the home of the Free and the land of the Brave. We will all be prizoners of the Federal Goverment and I guess we are already. We are taxed to death and no one seems to care in Washington. Just so they can get their piece of the pie. Don’t touch their funds.

    Reply
  261. Susan

    Like David, I too had to complete one of these forms this year to get my passport. I submitted a valid certified birth certificate with a stamp and all (and no, there are no irregularities around my birth) along with a copy of my state issued driver’s license (verified by the post office worker at the passport acceptance facility). I filled it out, telling the state department every address I’ve ever had, every job I’ve ever had, names of all my immediate family and every school I’ve gone to coupled with tons of identity documents and got my passport about 5 days later. I’m glad I got my passport, but I still feel violated and don’t understand why most of the information I submitted was relevant.
    So yes, people are being asked to do this already, and it’s not just people who don’t have valid ID/proof of citizenship.

    Reply
  262. Michelle

    Just checking back in to this thread as it was getting full of knee-jerk reactions and off topic. I should not contribute so it keeps going, but I have to ask:
    From earlier comments:
    3. How does this help our current immigration problem? <– what has this got to do with getting a passport?
    We are taxed to death <– seriously?! Take a look, our tax rates are not that high, haven't been for decades. Yes, they are higher than paying no tax at all. Many countries with higher tax rates actually have happier and more satisfied citizens. Maybe the USA problem is the return on investment; or maybe Americans are greedy and only want to help themselves instead of the community/all US citizens?

    Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. State Dept adding intrusive, semi-impossible questionnaire for US passport applications | Battery and Charger Forum - [...] State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport [...]
  2. State Dept adding intrusive, semi-impossible questionnaire for US passport applications | boomeroo - [...] State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport [...]
  3. You want to go to Europe and your government won’t give you a passport | Picking Cherries - [...] appears it won’t be that easy to get a passport for some people, trapped in your country and no…
  4. Guess what people, they be planning to keep you trapped in the US « InvestmentWatch - [...] http://www.consumertraveler.com/today/state-dept-wants-to-make-it-harder… [...]
  5. State Dept. Proposes Creepy, Impossible-To-Answer Questions for Passport Applications - Hit & Run : Reason Magazine - [...] Balko | April 25, 2011 Not really sure what to make of this, other than that it's [...]
  6. State Dept. Proposes Creepy, Impossible-To-Answer Questions for Passport Applications | The Agitator - [...] really sure what to make of this, other than that it’s disturbing: The U.S. Department of State is proposing…
  7. No Passports For You And Me - INGunOwners - [...] or pleasure. Fortunately, this is still a project in the works and it can be commented on. State Dept.…
  8. Warning to USA Folks: Passports May Soon be Harder to Obtain - [...] State Department is proposing a new Biographical Questionnaire for some passport applications…and their demands are a little [...]
  9. A Scintilla of Hope | Truth and Justice For All - [...] It was pretty horrendous.  Now comes more information, some analysis and some outrage, from Consumer Traveler.  It doesn’t get…
  10. Random Thoughts (Political Edition) - Page 263 - [...] http://www.consumertraveler.com/toda...et-a-passport/ State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport If you don’t want it to get…
  11. Weekend Round-Up: Best of the Travel Blogs (and websites)! - [...] Oh great, another way to make Americans dumber and insular – the US State Department wants to make it…
  12. State Dept adding intrusive, semi-impossible questionnaire for US passport applications | LandoftheFreeish.com - [...] Source [...]
  13. Does The Government Not Want Us To Travel? » A Dangerous Business - [...] couple of days ago, I read a worrisome post at Consumer Traveler regarding the passport application process in the…
  14. So Much For the Freedom to Travel: US Lowers Iron Curtain on Citizens « Women Born Transsexual - [...] From Consumer Traveler: http://www.consumertraveler.com/today/state-dept-wants-to-make-it-harder-to-get-a-passport/ [...]
  15. State Dept Looking To Limit Issuance of Passports « The Police State - [...] http://www.consumertraveler.com/today/state-dept-wants-to-make-it-harder-to-get-a-passport/ [...]
  16. Papiere, bitte! « Curses! Foiled Again! - [...] at Snowflakes in Hell points us to a disturbing proposal by the Dept of State. The U.S. Department of…
  17. State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport | Jonathan Carline's Law Of Power - [...] State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport This entry was posted in World News. Bookmark…
  18. No Passport For You? | 5 Min. Forecast - [...] proposed new Form DS-5513," writes Edward Hasbrouck at the Consumer Traveler blog, "asks for all addresses since birth; lifetime…
  19. State Department wants passport applicants to reveal lifetime employment history « Organic News Net - [...] “The State Department estimated that the average respondent would be able to compile all this information in just 45…
  20. Obama Administration Wants All Sorts of Info About You - Christian Forums - [...] Administration Wants All Sorts of Info About You The state department wants to make it harder for you to…
  21. Balloon Juice » “Your Papers, Citizen?” - [...] Per the Consumer Traveler website: [...]
  22. State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport - PerfectUnion Firearms Forum - [...] [...]
  23. Morning Links – Identified « Arresting Development - [...] Every time I pass through US immigration, I feel bad for foreign entrants; soon I may be feeling the…
  24. State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport /  We know and will tell you all what really happened today - [...] Edward Hasbrouck Consumer Traveler [...]
  25. State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport « CRISISBOOM - [...] consumertraveler [...]
  26. You Might Need Your Mom’s Pre And Post Natal Birth Records To Get A Passport : Stop The ACLU - [...] Trigerism. Anyhow, moving on to the originator of the story, found, shockingly, via Raw Story, at Consumer Traveler If…
  27. You Might Need Your Mom’s Pre And Post Natal Birth Records To Get A Passport » Pirate's Cove - [...] Trigerism. Anyhow, moving on to the originator of the story, found, shockingly, via Raw Story, at Consumer Traveler If…
  28. DC Caller:New passport rules will keep you grounded (forever) | The Party Of Know - [...] Don’t believe me? Check out the proposed new passport requirements: “Form DS-5513 asks for all addresses since birth; lifetime…
  29. Want a U.S. Passport? Not so fast, tell us about your Mom and work history « News « William K. Wolfrum Chronicles - [...] Consumer Traveler: The U.S. Department of State is proposing a new Biographical Questionnaire for some passport [...]
  30. You Might Need Your Mom’s Pre And Post Natal Birth Records To Get A Passport | News Patriot - [...] Trigerism. Anyhow, moving on to the originator of the story, found, shockingly, via Raw Story, at Consumer Traveler If…
  31. You Might Need Your Mom’s Pre And Post Natal Birth Records To Get A Passport | News Patriot - [...] Trigerism. Anyhow, moving on to the originator of the story, found, shockingly, via Raw Story, at Consumer Traveler If…
  32. State Dept wants to make it nearly impossible to get a passport | B12 Solipsism - [...] (click here to continue reading State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport.) [...]
  33. Google Shared – 2011/04/26 | Varsányi Krisztina Martina - [...] State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport [...]
  34. Don’t LIke How Things Are Going in the US? Well, It’s About to Get Harder to Escape « Scott Rhymer: Historian and Writer - [...] State Dpartment has decided to create a new set of onerous rules for getting your pasport. The Foggy Bottom…
  35. NEW PASSPORT REQUIREMENTS COMING SOON: STATE DEPARTMENT CONTINUES TO SQUEEZE FREEDOM | Truth Survival - [...] State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport [...]
  36. State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport | Dylan Ratigan - [...] wppa_bgcolor_img = "#eeeeee";wppa_popup_nolink = false;wppa_fadein_after_fadeout = false;wppa_animation_speed = 600;wppa_imgdir = "http://www.dylanratigan.com/wp-content/plugins/wp-photo-album-plus/images/";wppa_auto_colwidth = false;wppa_thumbnail_area_delta = 9;wppa_textframe_delta = 179;wppa_box_delta = 16;wppa_ss_timeout…
  37. Quicklinx for the Week of 4/25 (see Quicklinx page above for previous) « - [...] State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport – The proposed new  Form DS-5513 asks for…
  38. Soviet Style Travel Restrictions Coming to Amerika? | Real News Reporter - [...] Soviet Style Travel Restrictions Coming to Amerika? Posted by Real News Reporter on April 26th, 2011 var addthis_product =…
  39. Big Brother Digging Deeper Into Your Past. « Does It All Matter 2 - [...] http://www.consumertraveler.com/today/state-dept-wants-to-make-it-harder-to-get-a-passport/ [...]
  40. Papers, Please! » Blog Archive » Public outrage at proposed questionnaire for passport applicants - [...] the mainstream media didn’t pick up the story until after we wrote about the filing of our comments at…
  41. harlemviews - [...] Collection: DS-5513, Biographical Questionnaire for U.S. Passport, 1405-XXXX [Federal Register via Consumer Traveler] This entry was posted in Uncategorized.…
  42. The "NEW" passports - Old Hippie's Forums - [...] State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport Every place I lived? Every place I worked,…
  43. State Dept. Wants to Make It Harder to Get a Passport | Lost in the 21st Century - [...] via State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport. [...]
  44. State Department Wants Passport Applicants to Reveal Lifetime Employment History » Musicians for Freedom - [...] the amount of research that is likely to be required to even attempt to complete the form,” Consumer Traveler’s…
  45. Want to try and get a passport? Good luck with that… | a12iggymom's Blog - [...] Consumer Traveler reports that The US Department of State is proposing a series of new forms needed to in…
  46. New US passport requirements for Americans to leave the country!??!?!? | Caldwell TEA Party - [...] really sure what to make of this, other than that it’s disturbing: The U.S. Department of State is proposing…
  47. Midday open thread - Online Political Blog - [...] your supervisors’ names, addresses and phone numbers. Some officials at the State Department want to make it harder for…
  48. It’s going to get harder to get a passport « 2tts Blog - [...] http://www.consumertraveler.com/today/state-dept-wants-to-make-it-harder-to-get-a-passport/ [...]
  49. State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport « Evil of indifference - [...] Via Consumer Traveler [...]
  50. The State Department wants to make it harder to get a passport « same crap - [...] Read this bullshit. (the article) [...]
  51. Elu24.com Want a U.S. passport? Were you circumcised? Were you baptized or circumcised? Who was present when you were born? Where did your mother work? These are sample questions that applicants - [...] “The State Department estimated that the average respondent would be able to compile all this information in just 45…
  52. Odds ‘n Sods: | Survival Blogs | Tribulation Survival | Learn About Survival News, Survival Preparations, Survival Safety, Survival Skills, Survival Storage, Survival Theology, Biological War, Survival Book Reviews, Guns and Weapons, Natural Disaste - [...] R. sent this news item: State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport. JWR Adds: That…
  53. Red Tape Passports « imbibingtheconstitution - [...] Tape Passports By imbibingtheconstitution As reported by the Daily Caller, The Blaze and Consumer Traveler, the State Department has proposed…
  54. A Dream Squashed? « Fiddle Dee Dee - [...] now it looks like it may be harder than hell to get a passport. The U.S. Department of State…
  55. WERE YOU CIRCUMCISED? New Passport May just ask that « Brain Cramps - [...] notes the near impossibility of the proposed application, too: The State Department estimated that the [...]
  56. POLICE STATE ALERT! State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport - [...] The U.S. Department of State is proposing a new Biographical Questionnaire for some passport applicants: The proposed new  Form…
  57. ConsumerTraveler.com – State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport « Mypupdaisy's Blog - [...] READ FULL STORY [...]
  58. The Passports, They are A Changing’ | BirthAction - [...] The Passports, They are A Changing’ var addthis_product = 'wpp-256'; var addthis_config = {"data_track_clickback":true};This was brought to me by…
  59. » I Am… A Blog By Any Other Name… - [...] I spotted a rather concerning bit about the United States government wanting to change what people need to provide…
  60. State Department wants passport applicants to reveal lifetime employment history « Women Born Transsexual - [...] “The State Department estimated that the average respondent would be able to compile all this information in just 45…
  61. Want a U.S. passport? Were you circumcised? « InvestmentWatch - [...] “The State Department estimated that the average respondent would be able to compile all this information in just 45…
  62. Why the Government Could Make it Nearly Impossible for You to Get a Passport | Worldwidemag - [...] Well, the laugh’s on us. We may not be literally building such a fence, but we are creating a…
  63. State Dept. Wants to Make it Harder to Get a Passport | Truth Is Scary - [...] ConsumerTraveler [...]
  64. ALERT… Please Act: State Department’s Ridiculously Invasive New Passport Application – Retaliation? – (Updated) | askmarion - [...] notes the near impossibility of the proposed application, [...]
  65. Want a U.S. passport? Were you circumcised? « Global Pop! - [...] “The State Department estimated that the average respondent would be able to compile all this information in just 45…
  66. State Department Proposes Absurd New Barriers To Obtaining A Passport « Pat Garofalo - [...] was 19. (It was dreadful, thanks for asking.) I can’t remember what my boss’ name was, which may be…
  67. Obama and the Birthers - [...] for government work!Just by comparison, the U.S. Dept. of State is going to change how citizens get their passports…
  68. Gas Prices, Bad Weather Slow Economy in First Quarter - Political Forum - [...] April 27, 2011 at 10:10 am Consider this. Some Jews escaped Germany when things began to look bad. Some…
  69. Monday’s Links for Curious People | Travel Guide And Holiday - [...] The US State Department wants to make it harder (if not impossible) to get a passport. Consumer Traveler [...]
  70. Dirt Track Digest » Blog Archive » Racin’ & Internet Stuff: - [...] http://www.consumertraveler.com/today/state-dept-wants-to-make-it-harder-to-get-a-passport/ [...]
  71. Monday’s Links for Curious People | Lifestyle News - [...] The US State Department wants to make it harder (if not impossible) to get a passport. Consumer Traveler [...]
  72. New passport application – Kafka’s Catch-22 « Da Mook - [...] particularly true if you don’t have a copy of your long form Birth Certificate. According to this story, many…
  73. Why the Government Could Make it Nearly Impossible for You to Get a Passport « Eyes Wide Open International - [...] the laugh’s on us. We may not be literally building such a fence, but we are creating a virtual…
  74. State Dept. wants to make it harder to get a passport - So you can't legally leave the USA - Stormfront - [...] [...]
  75. Public Diplomacy Fail: In Which I Visit The Repellant U.S. Embassy In Beijing, Have Words With a State Department Employee and Learn A Possible Way To Short-Circuit The Onerous New Passport Form | The Nomad Lawyer - [...] are a possible way of dealing with the onerous new passport application form that the State Department is attempting…
  76. Blount County (BC) Public Record » State Department wants passport applicants to reveal lifetime employment history - [...] “The State Department estimated that the average respondent would be able to compile all this information in just 45…
  77. Number 203 | The New Terrapin Gazette - [...] have a passport but you might want to visit Canada or Mexico for a few hours, click on the…
  78. ConsumerTraveler most-read stories of 2011 - [...] please add them to the comments. We’ll try our best to research and publish them. 1. State Dept. wants…
  79. State Dept. admits passport form was illegal, but still wants it approved - [...] send you either or both of the new “long forms.” Early last year, the State Department proposed a new…
  80. 95% of Americans Dead Within 5 to 15 Years? Should White Americans Leave America? - Stormfront - [...] 5 to 15 Years? Should White Americans Leave America? Regarding passports; check out this site: State Dept. wants to…
  81. Tibet, The EuroZone, And Back Home– Open Borders Closing? Passports Becoming Harder To Get? | City of Travel - […] It’s a movement that the U.S. isn’t exactly immune to either. In fact, this week the State Department is…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *