Travelers are understandably confused by recent news about the REAL ID Act and new ID requirements for passengers on domestic flights within the U.S.
Accurate public understanding of what’s going on is not helped by the fact that the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, in official statements by its highest officials, on its official website have been telling out-and-out lies about what the law does and doesn’t require.
Many well-meaning and reputable but overly trusting journalists have allowed themselves to be used as conveyor belts for this DHS propaganda. The result has been a flood of authoritative-seeming news reports, many of them flatly wrong.
The essential facts are as follows:
In order to try to intimidate state governments into allowing their state driver licenses and ID databases to be integrated into a distributed national ID database (the REAL ID Act is about the database, not the ID cards), the DHS is threatening states. DHS intimates that at some future date set at the discretion of the DHS (not earlier than 2018, but that date has already been postponed by a decade since I first wrote about it, and could be postponed again) the TSA and its minions will start preventing people from flying if they show up at airports with ID from states that the DHS, in its discretion, deems insufficiently “compliant” with the federal REAL ID Act.
The DHS and the TSA have no legal authority to carry out this threat. The right to travel by air is guaranteed by explicit Federal law (“the public right of freedom of transit through the navigable airspace”, 49 US Code § 40101), by the Bill of Rights (“the right of the people… peaceably to assemble”, U.S. Constitution, Amendment 1), and by an international human rights treaty to which the USA is a party (“Everyone lawfully within the territory of a State [i.a. a country that is a party to the ICCPR] shall, within that territory, have the right to liberty of movement”, ICCPR, Article 12, Paragraph 3).
The TSA itself has said repeatedly, under oath, in court, that no law or regulation requires anyone to show any ID to fly within the USA. People fly without ID every day, and the TSA has procedures for that, as I’ve heard TSA witnesses testify and TSA lawyers argue in court, and as TSA responses to my FOIA requests have confirmed. So far as I have been able to determine — and I’ve looked hard — no court has ever reviewed, much less upheld, any ID requirement for domestic flights within the U.S.
If Congress doesn’t repeal the REAL-ID Act (bills to repeal the REAL ID Act are being introduced in both houses of Congress), the DHS threats to harass, delay or prevent people without ID it deems “acceptable” from flying, are certain to be challenged in court, and likely to be overturned as unconstitutional.
Here are more details in a series of articles posted in the last two weeks in the REAL-ID category on the Identity Project blog at PapersPlease.org:
- You don’t have to show any ID to fly (December 28, 2015)
- DHS posts new lies about the REAL-ID Act (January 4, 2016)
- My testimony to the Minnesota Legislative Working Group on REAL-ID Act Compliance (January 7, 2016)
- The REAL-ID Act is about the database, not the ID cards (January 8, 2016)
- DHS doubles down on its big lie about ID to fly (January 8, 2016)
If you have 15 minutes and would rather watch video or listen to audio than read, there’s an overview of the REAL-ID Act in this presentation delivered last spring at the Cato Institute, a think tank in Washington, DC. And I explain the current situation in this interview yesterday with Texas Public Radio.
Right now, U.S. domestic travelers don’t need to do anything about their ID cards. However, they do need to tell Congress to repeal the REAL ID Act, and ask state officials to prepare to defend your rights and those of other residents of your state if the DHS and/or TSA try to interfere with American’s right to travel.
The winner of a 2003 Lowell Thomas Travel Journalism award for investigative reporting from the Society of American Travel Writers Foundation for his in-depth reporting on the privacy of travel records, Hasbrouck protects the freedom to travel, the privacy of travelers, and their right to control how personal travel records are used by travel companies and government agencies.
Thanks, Ed. You have consistently been a voice of reason in all this (so has Charlie), unlike the doomsday-scenario speakers so prevalent on travel blogs. You’ve said from the beginning that DHS would blink, and you were right.
And thanks for reiterating the fact that flying is a right, not just a privilege. Another thing some people (such as TSA apologists) would do well to remember.
Flying is no more a “right” than driving is. To even think so is ridiculous!
Perhaps you missed Hasbrouck’s citations, paulette. They’re up there plain as day, with links. Here they are again:
The right to travel by air is guaranteed by explicit Federal law (“the public right of freedom of transit through the navigable airspace”, 49 US Code § 40101), by the Bill of Rights (“the right of the people… peaceably to assemble”, U.S. Constitution, Amendment 1), and by an international human rights treaty to which the USA is a party (“Everyone lawfully within the territory of a State [i.a. a country that is a party to the ICCPR] shall, within that territory, have the right to liberty of movement”, ICCPR, Article 12, Paragraph 3).
Furthermore:
The TSA and people of privilege
By Sommer Gentry | January 20, 2013
In Kent v. Dulles (357 US 116), the Supreme Court wrote these words, which appear three times in the decision:
“The right to travel is a part of the ‘liberty’ of which a citizen cannot be deprived without the due process of law of the Fifth Amendment.”
http://tsanewsblog.com/8853/news/the-tsa-and-people-of-privilege/
Well, driving per se is not an enumerated right, but for those who do, driving from one place to another–freely, without having to submit to unreasonable search and seizure absent probable cause or warrant–IS DEFINITELY A RIGHT. Same thing is true of flying.
Somebody’s ridiculous, all right, and it isn’t Edward Hasbrouck or people who quote him.
As others have pointed out to you, flying is a right and you should have read the entire article, including the US Code, before you posted and made yourself look ridiculous.
Please put your bias aside and honestly learn about this. A more informed public is a much safer, more free public.
How are the two even similar?
If you are driving then you need to be licensed. Same as if you are piloting the airplane. But riding as a passenger requires no license or permit other than the permission of the driver/flyer. In the case of airlines that permission is gained by purchasing a ticket but government has no say in that private transaction.
Saying that flying is not a right is the same as saying walking somewhere is not a right. The means of travel doesn’t matter, the fact is that free movement is a right.
Why are you so eager to give up your rights?
I would be interested to see someone who is knowledgeable on the issue to post a differing opinion and then decide how I feel about it. Clearly Edward is passionate, but I’m certain there is another side to the issue. I’d like to see what others have to say to be better informed.
Which part — REAL ID Act? Right to fly?
Would you accept quotes from the TSA or DHS as a knowledgable, differing opinion?
Maybe you would like to start with a history of REAL ID:
http://www.ncsl.org/research/transportation/history-behind-the-real-id-act.aspx
I would also ask you: Why does ID matter if a person getting on a plane is free of WEI?
https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2005/05/real_id.html
https://www.schneier.com/crypto-gram/archives/2004/0215.html#6
https://www.schneier.com/crypto-gram/archives/2004/0415.html#1
Why must another person present another side in order for you to form an opinion? You only need to read about the issue yourself. Then you can craft your very own opinion instead of choosing one of someone else.
“You only need to read about the issue yourself.”
That is what I want to do – so I can form an honest opinion. Reading blogs, as in the article above, where someone clearly has an agenda is too one sided. BTW – I’m not saying that Edward is wrong. I just want to read more about it. Thank you, Susan the for links. I’ll read them.
I guess pauletteb can’t defend her statements or else she would have returned to do so.