Regional airlines lie about codesharing in USA Today op-ed

codesharing
Given space for a rebuttal on the same page with today’s USA Today editorial, When airlines share codes, truth-in-labeling suffers, president Roger Cohen of the Regional Airline Association (RAA) trots out the airlines’ usual “big lie” on code sharing, in unusually blatant form:

As complex as travel may seem today, it was far more inefficient previously…. Passengers have to purchase only one ticket, have to check in bags on only one airline and have to clear security only once. Before code-sharing, passengers needed to buy tickets on separate airlines, often needed to claim and recheck bags, and might have needed to clear security in multiple terminals.

That’s an out-and-out lie, and the RAA must know it’s a lie.

Decades before code sharing was ever imagined, passengers could, in fact, buy a single ticket for a journey on multiple airlines, and check their bags through. (Today, of course, thanks to a different airline fraud called a “direct” flight with a change of equipment, inbound passengers on what is labeled as a single flight with a single number may have to claim and recheck their bags as well as change planes and perhaps terminals at an international gateway.)

Not one of these services requires alliances or code sharing. They are all aspects of “interlining”, in which “regional”, national, and international airlines, including competitors, all had interline ticketing and baggage agreements in place from the earliest days of the airline industry. All airlines in the U.S. were regional in the early days, and interlining was essential to coast-to-coast travel. Just as it had been for the railroads, from whom the earliest airlines developed their interline protocols: until Amtrak, no single railroad crossed the U.S. Interlining is one of the oldest and most fundamental foundations of the airline industry, in the U.S. and worldwide.

The international standards that the airlines themselves established decades ago through IATA permit all IATA member airlines, not just code-share or alliance partners, to publish through fares and establish interline ticketing and baggage transfer agreements. Any IATA-appointed travel agency can sell tickets on any IATA airline, including tickets at a single through fare for a multi-airline journey. Different airlines that want to facilitate interline transfers can use close-together gates at the same terminals, so that passengers don’t need to go through extra security checkpoints, regardless of which airlines’ flight number(s) they use. And even airlines that are members of the major marketing alliances often give frequent flyer mileage credit for travel on non-alliance airlines, without code sharing. Interline ticketing agreements — not code sharing — are also what enable airlines to endorse their tickets to other airlines, even competitors if necessary, if their own flights are cancelled, delayed, or overbooked.

Code sharing is unnecessary for, indeed irrelevant to, any legitimate purpose or actual service. Code sharing doesn’t enable an airline to fly to any more places. It just enables the airline to mislead travelers into thinking that they fly to places they don’t, and mislead them as to which airline will actually be operating their flights. Major U.S.-based airlines, regional airlines, and foreign airlines all participate in code sharing, when they can get away with it, because they correctly believe that customers are more likely to buy tickets, and will pay more for those tickets, if they are for flights on Air Established than on Air Unknown or Air Foreign. I call that fraud.

Both code sharing and “change-of-equipment” flight labels also serve to “game” the Computerized Reservations Systems used by both offline and online travel agencies for fraudulent purposes, to travelers’ detriment. All else except the labeling being equal, CRSs rank and display purportedly same-airline connections ahead of honestly described interline connections, and purportedly “through” change-of-equipment flights ahead of honestly described connections between multiple flights.

USA Today rightly editorializes that codesharing “presents a truth-in-advertising problem”, an issue entirely ignored in the RAA rebuttal. In another recent press release the RAA claims that, “The identity of the airline is clearly displayed on every single ticket.” But that’s a lie, too, as I pointed out in the most recent Department of Transportation rulemaking on disclosure of code shares:

While itineraries usually indicate the operating airline, tickets and boarding passes — the things travelers are required to have in hand while searching for a flight or gate, even if they don’t have a printed itinerary — do not. Indeed, IATA and airline rules provide no field on a ticket or boarding pass for the designation of the operating airline, and forbid the entry of other information in those fields. A travel agent who wants to indicate on a ticket which airline actually operates a code-share flight is forbidden from doing so by airline ticket issuance rules and procedures.

It’s airline lies like today’s from the RAA that demonstrate the need for Federal action to protect consumers against airline fraud, including fraudulent code sharing, as I’ve been saying for years.

Previous

Next

5 Comments

  1. Doug

    Maybe I’m not understanding this correctly. I think the editorials were incorrect, but not for the reasons you state. It seems to me they are both confusing the terms “code sharing” and “regional carrier”.

    To me, a code share is when I buy a ticket on an airline (for example, United), but the flight is actually flown by US Air. The aircraft is painted with US Air’s colours, the check in is at US Air’s desk, and the flight departs from US Airs gates, and operates under a US Air flight number.

    The examples they are giving indicate the flight is operated by another carrier using the main carriers colours and logo’s. The flights depart from the main carriers gates and check in is handled at the main carriers desk. That isn’t what I’ve always understood code sharing to be. That sounds more like a regional or junior carrier flying exclusively for the main carrier under contract.

    I think there are pro’s and cons to both code sharing and regional airlines, but both the op-ed and rebuttal don’t really address either one of the them.

    Reply
    • Charlie Leocha

      Doug,
      You understand it correctly. The smaller planes that are painted with the USAir colors, that have USAir flight numbers, and that have a check in at the USAirways counter are not run or owned by USAirways. They are code-shares. It is a fraud instituted to make passengers think USAirways has a more extensive route. The planes are owned by another carrier. The pilots are hired by another carrier. The safety operations are under another carrier. Nothing is USAir except the paint job and that is paid for by another carrier.
      This is one example of a code-share. This is the example that is causing the most consternation in DC after the Continental Express flight that crashed in Buffalo. Many thought it was a Continental flight. It was not. It was a Colgan Air flight disguised as Continental and the passengers did not know that.
      Other code-shares come about when people buy a USAir flight numbered flight through USAirways, but the flight is operated by United. That is more obvious once passengers see the plane. However many passengers do not know that the plane will be operated by United until they get to the flight.
      The system is one of smoke and mirrors that depends on federally accepted fraud.

      Reply
  2. jlawrence01

    It sort of reminds me of the now discontinued United Airlines out of Rockford, IL. You booked a ticket from Rockford with a stop in O’Hare.

    When you arrived at the airport, you were placed on a bus and driven to O’Hare. Of course, this was not disclosed until you got to the airport.

    Reply
  3. Greg Fischer

    Your argument is sound because you know the history and details surrounding interlining that underlie the system and as you so correctly point out, came from the structure the railroads had developed long before anyone could imagine either Amtrak of airline code-sharing.

    Unfortunately the public and lawmakers are too likely to swallow the fabrication of history that the RAA puts out because they don’t know the past, or for that matter the still largely intact interline system that survives to this day with the exception of some go-it-alone carriers.

    Having begun in the travel industry in 1979 on the airline side, I remember a system where many more regional airlines worked far more harmoniously with a much greater number of trunk carriers, and all without the dubious “improvement” of code-sharing.

    Thank you for correcting the record. Let’s hope someone is listening.

    Reply
  4. Robert

    The author makes a good point regarding interlining and codesharing. Airlines would have us believe that we as consumers need code sharing but the truth is that codesharing is strictly a marketing tool. There could be no codesharing without interline agreements first. The technology for codesharing doesn’t work without interline agreements in place.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *